A Solder's Duty In Guests Of The Nation

2039 words - 8 pages

War evokes different emotions and feelings for many people. Some are drafted and forced to serve, others volunteer their lives for a cause they believe in and some never even see a battle ground. Some live, some die, others are captured and become prisoners or hostages. But one thing is certain, for those who have actually seen war know first hand that it has the power to change and in most cases it does just that. In Frank O'Connor's "Guests of the Nation," two British soldiers are captured by the Irish Republic Army. Two young Irish soldiers are assigned to guard the captives. The British earn the trust and friendship of their young captors. Until one day the call of duty forces the Irish to carry out orders that forever change their perspective on the war and the duty that accompanies. In "Guests of the Nation," O'Connor uses six elements of fiction to illustrate the conflict associated with the responsibility of duty and one's personal morals in the circumstance of war.

Although this is a story of war and there is obviously external conflict between the opposing countries, it is the internal conflict of the Irish soldiers Bonaparte and Noble that help the reader understand how the weight of duty ultimately defeats personal morals during war. It is Bonaparte and Noble's duty as an Irish soldiers in the IRA (Irish Republic Army) to guard the two captured British soldiers. Bonaparte feels the two men do not even need guarding, that they would not flee given the chance. He and Noble both have become bored with docile cottage life and would rather be out in the action fighting. Bonaparte soon finds out that he and Noble are going to be relived of there guarding duties but not how either of them had anticipated. "It was the next morning that we found it so hard to face Belcher and Hawkins. We went about the house all day scarcely saying a word" (O'Connor 1097). Bonaparte and Noble are on edge all day with


the anticipation of weather or not they will have to execute the British soldiers they have come to

regard as friends. When the two men are given the orders that they will be executing Belcher and Hawkins they are overcome with guilt and moral responsibility. Neither Bonaparte nor Noble want to carry out the duty of execution. Bonaparte even hopes that the men would try to escape or fight knowing full well that he would never fire on them. "And all the time I was hoping that something would happen; that they'd run for it or that Noble would take over the responsibility from me. I had the feeling that it was worse on Noble than on me" (1099). This is a very harsh reality of the duties of war. They want for their friends to run away and relive them of their execution duty although it is their soldierly duty to obey the orders and kill them. There is internal conflict as to the duties and the personal feelings of responsibility that Bonaparte and Noble feel for what they know must be done to Belcher and Hawkins.


Find Another Essay On A Solder's Duty in Guests of the Nation

A Father of the Nation Essay

1444 words - 6 pages be stopped where it was, but it was not his ultimate goal to remove it from the nation. He needed the support of all in the Republican Party to gain candidacy, and calling for a full scale removal of slavery was not the route to go. Later on his speech continued to beg for the unification of the nation. He asked that the Northerners to not submit to the demands of the South, at the same time he asked the Southerners to realize that they were

The survival of a nation Essay

666 words - 3 pages Humans often make goals to reach an exhilarated state. When a goal becomes too hard to obtain and when too many people fail to reach this goal, society digresses. The American Dream is the national ethos of the United States that was created in 1931. It is a set of principles in which prosperity and success can be achieved through hard work and the right ethics. However, over the years, the “car has stopped.” This so-called “dream” is running

The Shaping Of A Nation

1154 words - 5 pages culprit who is going to the place of his execution, so unwilling am I, in the evening of a life nearly consumed in public cares, to quit a peaceful abode for an ocean of difficulties, without that competency of political skill, abilities and inclination which is necessary to manage the helm. He was adored by the new nation, inspired by his want for unity (“Washington“). His administration was dead-set on shining a light on

Controversial Minority Representation in the Film, Birth Of a Nation

1110 words - 4 pages Controversial Minority Representation in the Film, Birth Of a Nation     Birth of a Nation was a film that broke several artistic boundaries in the film industry yet was seen as the most racist film of any generation. This has caused it to be a film under heavy debate since its release in 1915. One can never look past the racist depictions that this film portrays in it. However, to truly understand the film and explore its importance in

The Duty of Women

1584 words - 6 pages The duty of women to have children creates a bias against them. Many laws for women and writings about women relate to their job of childbearing. It is their most important responsibility and also what gave them less freedoms then men. I will explore this fact in ancient Mesopotamia, Greece and Rome using the writings of Sappho, Aristotle and the scribe Any. The first laws regarding women that we have record of was Hammurabi’s code. In

Reflective Journal - A Nurse's Duty in the Surgical Ward

1043 words - 4 pages in the recovery unit, I was able to talk to one of the recovery nurses. I learnt that a nurse’s duty of care includes monitoring the patient’s vital signs and level of consciousness, and maintaining airway patency. Assessing pain and the effectiveness of pain management is also necessary. Once patients are transferred to the surgical ward, the goal is to assist in the recovery process, as well as providing referral details and education on care required when the patient returns home (Hamlin, 2010).

Herb is the Healing of a Nation

1562 words - 6 pages Herb is the Healing of a Nation Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are the sovereign rights of a man. This means every human should be able to live a fulfilling life as they see fit following dreams and aspirations until happiness and inner peace is achieved. From the dawn of human time expanding one’s conscious was the known path to enlightenment, self actualization, and ultimate happiness. People take all different routes whether it

The Importance of Duty in George Eliot's Silas Marner

3782 words - 15 pages to show kindness, generosity, and respect for the community, traditions and family. Duty is a large part of this novel and it is based upon the values of practical Christianity, in part one. In this novel, the people are clearly divided into two separate classes of people; those who neglect duty and are punished, and those who honour duty and are latter rewarded. In this novel, Silas himself has an obligation to Eppie

Duty of Care Policy in the Australian Education System

1879 words - 8 pages Introduction Duty of care is a legal concept originating from common law and is considered the driving force behind most school policies, guidelines and practices. Duty of care outlines the responsibility one must undertake to ensure that reasonable steps are in place to protect the safety or well-being of others. Within these parameters teachers must manage their classrooms and school activities, maintain order and discipline, and make every

The Building of A New Nation

718 words - 3 pages the biggest economic power in the world.To maintain a powerful and influential industry, technological advances are necessary. Inventions enhanced the idea of expanding the nation and dramatically accelerated the development of industry. Inventions such as the cotton gin and steamboat helped shape our nation. Invented by Eli Whitney, the cotton gin helped lead the United States in the leading producer of cotton in the world. This invention allowed

The Development of Canada as a Nation

1149 words - 5 pages The Development of Canada as a NationCherrisse PorterThere are different opinions about the most important event in Canada's development as a nation. The story starts with the voyager, warrior, and forefather of the second largest nation today, Samuel de Champlain. He is the famous French explorer who helped broaden the Europeans' understanding of Canada. Few persons in his era came to recognize the potential that North America had to offer in

Similar Essays

Morals And Orders In "Guests Of The Nation"

859 words - 3 pages determine what is right and wrong. Most people believe that the laws of society are right and it is our duty to follow them. The majority of people stop at a stop sign even when there is no one else at an intersection. Sometimes what is legally right and what is morally right do not coincide with each other. The characters in "Guests of the Nation" are forced to decide whether to follow orders or their stick to their own personal beliefs.It is

Guilty By Association/Essay On Frank O'connor's "Guests Of The Nation"

915 words - 4 pages The setting within Frank O’Connor’s “Guests of the Nation” helped support his central idea that inexperienced soldiers are at risk for emotional breakdowns. The story began by explaining how the two English soldiers Belcher and Hawkins, had been caught in war and were hostages of the Irish Republic Army (IRA). The English soldiers were guarded by a few IRA soldiers and sent to the residency of an old Irish woman. At the old

A Tale Of Duty Essay

736 words - 3 pages “Again and again he said, ’Are you happy, Jane?’ And again and again I answered, ‘Yes.’ After which he murmured, ‘It will atone – it will atone.’” Jane Eyre, written by Charlotte Bronte, and published in 1847, is a romantic, gothic novel with deep themes of duty, marriage, and faith. The book is the tale of an orphan girl named Jane Eyre, who endures a traumatic childhood under the poor care of her aunt, Mrs. Reed. Jane grows up to fall in love

The Defining Of A Nation Essay

908 words - 4 pages the beginning, to succeed.Another important aspect in defining America is the government under which it has operated for the last two-hundred years. Compared to the history of the world; however, our government is still an infant. Despite this, the representative democracy, under which this nation operates, has been a model government for newly formed governments around the world. This may be due to the fact that we have become one of the most
Fist of Zen (1) | Ch. 927-MangaStream - Chapter 927 | Qu ricos tan pobres