Compare The Play "Pygmalion" By George Bernard Shaw With Its Film Version "My Fair Lady". Which Do You Find More Effective Work Of Art And Why. Use Quotes

1908 words - 8 pages

Pygmalion written by Bernard Shaw, was first performed on stage with Rex Harrison as Henry Higgins. The reception of the audience during the play was of utmost disappointment due to the non romantic ending of the play, even though that was Shaw’s initial intentions. My fair Lady on the other hand is a musical based on Pygmalion, and the movie was shot in 1964 by director George Cukor. Although there are numerous similarities between musical and play such as the character interactions or how both of them portray social status, especially in the conclusion, the musical displays several contradictions in comparison to the movie.Bernard Shaw wrote the play during an important moment in history, which was when women were starting to gain independence in the beginning of the 20th century. It is produced in 1914 which is when WW1 broke out and war time made it easier for women to find work, and soon after women got their independent vote in 1920. Thus Pygmalion has a strong sense of feminism and independence as one of the leading themes to guide the characters on, especially Eliza.Eliza throughout the play is striving to prove how women should be independent and not rely on men in order to lead a life. Both movie and play shows us that when Higgins turns Eliza into a duchess, he didn’t give her just class and status but he took her independence away because she is “not fit to sell anything else”. What happens now is that if Eliza doesn’t marry she has no one to provide for her and Freddy is useless because he has no talent for making money. Thus Higgins indirectly limited Eliza’s opportunities making her dependent on men. And during the movie when she goes back to Higgins she loses power in her character. Even though it was of her own free will and not on necessity, she still loses the power she had before.Pygmalion comes from a Greek Myth, Ovid’s narrative where a man called Pygmalion makes a sculpture of a woman called Galatea. Ovid’s original idea is that Galatea would be a worshipping monument to Pygmalion with a woman who refuses to be bound to a man who says that he has “created” her. Shaw in a way is flouting with Ovid’s original purpose due to all the inferences even in Pygmalion that Higgins maybe has feelings for Eliza, supporting Shaw’s proposal of a woman within a low rank to dominate and gain the love of a middle class man. However, whether Eliza loves him or not is a different matter.On the other hand, Shaw has an ironic ending of Eliza marrying Freddy. So her independence goes straight into the gutter when she goes from being the subject of one man to another, because that is the only thing an upper class woman is supposed to do in her life, just like when Mr. Doolittle said “I was free”. He wants to return to the “undeserving poverty” instead of living as a rich man where everyone wants something from him, including his wife now wants to marry him.What...

Find Another Essay On Compare the play "Pygmalion" by George Bernard Shaw with its film version "My fair lady". Which do you find more effective work of art and why. Use quotes

Pygmalion By Bernard Shaw Essay

974 words - 4 pages dignity and independence, but eventually she gave in and was molded into a lady. • Colonel Pickering: Pickering is the closest thing to a father figure for Eliza. Without his suggestion, the whole bet would have never happened. Eliza credits Pickering’s gentlemanly ways for starting her transformation to a lady by making her feel like one. • My mom told me that Pygmalion is the script for the play “My Fair Lady,” and gave me a summary. It sounded

Pygmalion a Play by Bernard Shaw

1689 words - 7 pages summary of the play will be provided. Next, the theme of language and social class will be addressed. The last part will be devoted to the theme of gender and specifically the position of women. George Bernard Shaw’s play Pygmalion is based on an ancient Greek myth where a sculptor fell in love with a statue he created himself. In this play, Shaw tells a story of the protagonist, Eliza Doolittle, a poor flower girl who is taught by the professor of

"Pygmalion" by George Bernard Shaw and "Tess of the D'Urbervilles" by Thomas Hardy

1355 words - 5 pages Some story lines overwhelm their heroes or heroines with good luck. Sometimes characters experience misfortune at the beginning of their story but later emerge with their situations resolved. Other times, however, the entire story line works almost completely against the hero or heroine's will until the end. Both Tess of the d'Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy and Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw feature a female character who experiences several

Analysis of George Bernard Shaw´s Pygmalion

911 words - 4 pages London. The reason why Shaw chose for this setting is quite obvious, since it is the time period in which he lived and London was his birthplace. However, the setting is also important for the story. To begin with, in this period of time the pattern of social mobility was changing. If you were born in a lower class family, you could climb up the social ladder by working hard, like Eliza. Secondly, the position of women in society was changing. Women

Metamorphosis of Eliza Doolittle in Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw

1688 words - 7 pages The Metamorphosis of Eliza Doolittle in Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw   The benefits of acquiring an education are not limited to the academic aspects often associated with it. Part of the edification it bestows includes being enabled to reach new insight, being empowered to cultivate a new awareness, and being endowed with a new understanding of life and of self. In Bernard Shaw's Pygmalion, Eliza Doolittle experiences this type of

Pygmalion By George Shaw

1051 words - 5 pages Pygmalion by George ShawShaw "the second greatest English playwright, behind only Shakespeare"Title- Shaw called Pygmalion a potboiler and subtitled it "A Romance." Thus the play's main thematic concern is romantic in the literary use of the term. It is a play that has a highly improbable plot. Professor Henry Higgins transforms a common flower girl into a graceful lady, like the legendary Greek sculptor Pygmalion carved an exquisite female

Pygmalion My Fair Lady

632 words - 3 pages Pygmalion & My Fair Lady      The play Pygmalion and My Fair Lady, the musical, are the same story. The only major difference between the two, is that My Fair Lady has songs added to the dialogue. I believe the musical version is more enjoyable because the music adds more feeling to the story.      The opening scene is after an opera. The higher class people spill out into the streets. It

Analysis of Arms and the Man by George Bernard Shaw

950 words - 4 pages Analysis of Arms and the Man by George Bernard Shaw "Arms and the Man" starts with gunfire on a dark street in a small town. The romantic and willful Raina is about to begin her true-life adventure by sheltering the handsome fugitive Bluntschli, enemy of her equally handsome fiancé Sergius The setting of the play is in war-torn Bulgaria, and focuses not only on the romance between the young people of the play, but the atrocities

Compare The Birthing Scene In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, Directed By Kenneth Branagh (1994) With The Original Version Directed By James Whale (1931). Which Do You Think Is Most Effective And Why?

1361 words - 5 pages . The James Whale is considered by many people to be a classic because it is still being watched some 70 years later. Although "˜Mary Shelley's Frankenstein' by Kenneth Branagh is still too modern to be considered a classic, I think in years to come it will still be being watched as one of the best "˜Frankenstein' adaptations.I think "˜Frankenstein' is the type of film that improves as technology develops, allowing better special effects, and, to some extent, reality. The Kenneth Branagh version pays more attention to detail and I preferred his portrayal of Victor. I think this makes Kenneth Branagh's "˜Mary Shelley's Frankenstein' more effective.

Pygmalion vs. My Fair Lady

674 words - 3 pages Pygmalion vs. My Fair LadyThe Academy Award-winning musical film My Fair Lady produced by George Cukor in 1964, was based on the play Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw written in 1913. Although, the basic story line and underlying themes are the same, there are a number of differences between the two famous works. The most pronounced difference is that My Fair Lady had songs added to the dialogue. Furthermore, Pygmalion deals with many of the

Pygmalion Vs My Fair Lady

627 words - 3 pages Pygmalion vs My Fair LadyGeorge Bernard Shaw wrote Pygmalion in the early 20th century. Later that century a musical was released named My Fair Lady. The Musical is a copy of the work Shaw did. The musical has the same characters, setting, and situations. The Musical on the other hand differs greatly from the book Pygmalion. The character development in the musical adds a great deal to the story. The way the musical fills in the gaps that the

Similar Essays

How Does The Relationship Between Eliza Doolittle And Henry Higgins Change Throughout The Play? Pygmalion By George Bernard Shaw Also Known As My Fair Lady

1212 words - 5 pages Untitled Pygmalion is a play based on the Greek myth of a sculptor named Pygmalion who said that he didn't like women. One day he creates a statue of a beautiful woman, and regrets saying that he didn't like women. Aphrodite turns the statue into a real woman so her and the sculptor marry and spend the rest of their lives together. Bernard Shaw has put a `modern' twist on this myth using Higgins as Pygmalion, Eliza as the

Pygmalion By George Bernard Shaw Essay

1132 words - 5 pages shows us how quickly we judge people by what they do and what they look like and not on what they are. Further on in the play the labelling of the characters changes, "the flower girl" changes to "Liza", "the gentleman" to "Pickering" and "the note taker" to "Higgins" by using first names and surnames we can see where the characters have been placed with in the class system. Using detailed stage directions Shaw shows how materialistic things

"Pygmalion" By George Bernard Shaw Essay

825 words - 3 pages "Pygmalion" by George Bernard Shaw'Pygmalion' is set in the late 1800s, during the Victorian age, when the distinction between the social-economic classes was very clearly made. Shaw made this issue one of the themes of this play and unveiled the "markers" people of the era had used to judge and evaluate one another. These 'yardsticks' include - articulation of the English language, wealth, social status, dressing and education.The members of

Social Classes In George Bernard Shaw’s "Pygmalion" And The Movie "My Fair Lady"

568 words - 2 pages George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion, is a humorous, yet moral, play that portrays the active social classes and lifestyles in Britain. The play features the main character Henry Higgins, a professor of phonetics, who embarks on the formidable task of teaching a flower girl, Eliza Doolittle, how to speak English properly, and then passing her off as a duchess at the royal ball. Pygmalion was later adapted into the film, My Fair Lady in 1964, and
Read Essay | RC Multicopter | Download Now