Is The Western Australian Response To Shark Attacks An Example Of A Moral Panic?

1390 words - 6 pages

The Western Australian (WA) response to shark attacks, that is the shark cull, is an example of a moral panic. Moral panics are not a new concept to modern society; episodes of panic, anxiety or alarm over numerous forms of perceived threats an element of society. Many studies have been conducted since Stanley Cohen first addressed the concept in 1972 with his book ‘Folk Devils and Moral Panics: The Creation of the Mods and Rockers’ – including that of Erich Goode and Nachman Ben-Yehuda (Moral Panics: The Social Construction of Deviance). A combination of these two studies results in what Brian Klocke and Glenn Muschert defined as a ‘Hybrid Model’ (Klocke and Muschert, 2010) to determine moral panics in a contemporary world; one where the “widespread concept of moral panic…in recent decades has obscured its conceptual coherence” (Krinsky, 2013).

Perceived threats to the ‘moral fabric of society’ (OED Online, 2014), moral panics (as agreed by most sociologists who have studied and explored the phenomenon) to a great degree take place in the media. Cohen not only emphasized the crucial role of media in the constructions of moral panic, but also established a five-part process to moral panics:
1. Behavior by folk devils is defined as threat to societal values and interests.
2. The threat is depicted in a recognizable dramatic form by the media.
3. A rapid build-up of public concern arises.
4. Authorities, politicians and moral entrepreneurs call for a strong solution to the problem.
5. The panic recedes or results in social and institutional changes. (Krinsky, 2013)
Erich Goode and Nachman Ben-Yehuda then expanded on Cohen’s concept of moral panics in their study by outlining the elemental characteristics of a moral panic: concern, consensus, hostility, disproportionality and volatility (Goode and Ben-Yehuda, 2009). A combined understanding of these two models enables one to not only understand the concept of a moral panic, but forms a ‘Hybrid Model’ to enable the understanding that the WA response to shark attacks is in fact an example of a moral panic.

Moral panics require a form of scapegoat; an object or person in which public fears and fantasies can be projected. Arnold Hunt argues that it is more likely to be applied to vulnerable figures – such as singles mothers – than aggressive deviants or anti-social groups, such as the Youth Deviants discussed by Cohen in his case study. Being characteristically media driven, the modern day episode of a moral panic is arguably able to spread more efficiently due to the existence of more effective communication channels; including sensationalist mass media. This is evident in the analysis of the WA response to shark attacks in the form of media reports both pre-Shark Cull and post-Shark Cull. Before WA Premier Colin Barnett announced the ‘Shark Mitigation Policy’, numerous reports were made of shark attack victims; most notably that of Chris Boyd whom many identify as the catalyst that encouraged WA...

Find Another Essay On Is the Western Australian Response to Shark Attacks an Example of a Moral Panic?

How does deviancy amplification spiral operate to cause a 'moral panic'

615 words - 2 pages Describe in your own words how the deviancy amplification spiral operates to produce a 'moral panic'. Illustrate with two examples.A non-sociological or common sense explanation of 'moral panic' would describe it as a justified reaction to a real threat to the moral fabric of society. However under closer inspection 'moral panic' is a complex social construction with many underlying factors. The deviancy amplification spiral (Cohen 1970s OU

The Perfect Moral Example Essay

1312 words - 5 pages , neither of the cruel sisters was allowed to marry him (611). This is yet another example of how cruelty does not get people what they want. This story and many others teach children to be good people and follow the moral code of their culture through example rather than the parents telling them how to act. Fairytales are more than simply good bedtime stories. They imply a distinct set of moral values, and provide examples of how not to act

The construct of the western democratic moral

1203 words - 5 pages accounts of moral conflict are based on the constructs created in a democratic western white society. Therefore, Lukes, Wolf and Berln offer an account of the concepts and themes pertaining to moral conflict that demonstrate that moral conflict and disagreement is dependant upon ones ability to have their issue politicised and made moral issues on the political agenda. That is, most moral issues are only moral issues as they are constructed and

A response to an atheist

1612 words - 7 pages thousands of rotations per second, stop almost instantaneously and reverse rotation almost without pausing. This functional unit is far more efficient and well-designed than any modern motor which man could even hope to design. It serves as an excellent example of irreducible complexity and intelligent design because the chances of all the right atoms coming together to form such a unit is unimaginably small. If McCloskey could only understand this and

This paper is a detailed example of the 4th amendment

651 words - 3 pages Maryland v. Pringle (02-809), which poses an important question about the meaning of the Fourth Amendment's probable cause requirement. A Baltimore County police officer arrested Joseph Pringle, the front seat passenger in a car stopped for a traffic violation, after finding five plastic baggies containing cocaine behind the backseat armrest during a consensual search. The officer had threatened to arrest all three occupants the driver/owner, the back

The Australian Hero: An overview of what is a hero and how it has changed over time

742 words - 3 pages Football League. Many Australian's follow it religiously. Sport is part of our everyday lives; it is televised in the news, on special sports report and reviews.HOW DO THE MEDIA CONSTRUCT HEROISM IN AUSTRALIAN SOCIETY?Popular culture plays an important role in representing and defining who is a hero within our society. The media generally categorises a hero according to their capabilities and achievements that have impacted society. For example, war

Is there a moral obligation to obey the law?

2788 words - 11 pages benefits, but also simpler things as the provision of roads, electricity, or water.If the benefits are considered 'substantial', they imply a moral obligation to obey the government's laws as an expression of gratitude.Although there are many ways to counter argue this argument, it is perhaps natural the argument appeals to people who find their government a just one.There are several counterarguments.It is argued for example, that the benefits of the

What Is A Hero?(A Response To The Odyssey)

566 words - 3 pages lose. A more pacific example is when he has to travel through the rocks where the monster ate some of his men even though he already knew this was going to happen.I chose Jesus as a "person" I admire as a role model and hero, for many reasons although he is hard to compare with Odysseus. I have a faithful and religious relationship with Jesus seeing as he is "dead". I admire him because he gave up his worldly life and put the weight of the worlds

Alcoholic Shark. A drunk Shark?! No, but a funny tale that is best read while intoxicated! A favorite of Marines!

1272 words - 5 pages for an endless source of customers. While they both were sergeants making only about seventy-five dollars every two weeks, a profit on a free fish seemed like a pretty good proposition.The only problem they had now was - how do you transport a shark to a military base that is thirty miles away? Riding in the back seat was definitely out.They waited around for the next ten minutes waiting for the oxygen to suck the life out of the victim. After

You are a consultant hired to advise a selected Australian manufacturer or service firm. The firm is considering making an entry into one of any two countries of your choice

8685 words - 35 pages analysis3.1Company analysisSuper Coffee Mix Manufacturing Ltd is an integrated manufacturer of instant beverages and popular convenience food products. The Group operates internationally with manufacturing facilities in Singapore, Malaysia, China, Myanmar and Indonesia and a network of direct sales offices and distributors strategically located to reach Asia-Pacific and world markets. About 80% of the Group's revenue comes from product sales in the Asia-Pacific

A Triangle Example of the Contributions to America

1070 words - 4 pages the example stated earlier about students and education describing human capital). In order for a group to receive human capital, they must migrate to a country where human capital is a factor. According to Dr. Smith, “Human capital has proven to be the independent variable that can best explain these groups success” (Smith 25). Scandinavians immigrants had sufficient amount of prestige that was recognized by the American people. During

Similar Essays

Western Australian Shark Cull Essay

1612 words - 7 pages conducting a doctoral thesis on the politics of shark attacks, has proclaimed, 'I'm befuddled by the rationale of how baiting sharks towards the beaches is meant to reduce the risk of a shark attack',. An example of the ineffectiveness of culling is a shark control program conducted in Hawaii in the 60's and 70's. They culled over 4600 sharks and yet shark attack numbers stayed exactly the same. This shows 100% proof that what the government is

9/11 Attacks And The Western Response

2029 words - 9 pages passengers of the plane that he was going to try to get the plane back and fly it to safety. Shortly after this, the passengers began to take back the plane. They caused the plane to go out of control. This took courage. A courage that is explained as constructive, a person or collective engages in actions of moral or social worth, but also confrontational, because they are acting in ways opposite of social norms, social pressures, expectations, and flow

What Is The Purpose Of Advertising? Essay Shows An Example Of The Purpose Of Advertising. (To Sell A Concept, Not A Product)

609 words - 2 pages concerned about health you say? Health shouldn't be an issue when you have Kool cigarettes. Think about all you can have, the popularity, the fame, the fortune, it's all there for you, just smoke Kool.Notice in my ad that the good-looking man has three beautiful women surrounding him, rooting him on while he gambles. How many of you guys have a difficult time getting just one woman to go anywhere with you let alone three sexy women? This man will never

‘Is Humanitarian Military Intervention An Example Of A Justified War.’

1464 words - 6 pages adapted and to modern standards – yet has it changed for the better? Walzer argues that just war theory is central to modern issues such as humanitarian intervention and terrorism. He illustrates how states will react when threats to the nation state is present (Walzer: 1980). Furthermore, the very concept that humanitarian intervention can be an example of a justified war suggests that states can play the role of moral agents in the international
Twice Dance Practice | Ralph Breaks the InternetDuration: 112 min | jautor's home theater