Efficacy Of Phonological Writing Treatment Essay

2294 words - 10 pages

Writing treatment for aphasia using phonological training works best when speaking nonsense. Either nonsense or Italian. Six writing treatment studies demonstrate that research for phonological training treatment is at Phase II. Such treatment would be in a Phase III level of evidence if the studies reviewed had quasi-experimental studies or closer examinations of efficacy. Phonological writing treatment is still in Phase II as illustrated by these three similarities in research efficacy: first, how inconsistent procedures in research obscure a standardized research protocol; second, how irrelevant outcomes confuse data; and third, how the lack of clearly defined participant characteristics mar research results. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that though writing treatment using phonological training may have some benefits for some patients with aphasia, the treatment is generally at a Phase II level of evidence with little sign of moving to the quasi-experimental Phase III level.
One barrier for phonological research to move to Phase III is inconsistent procedures. The cognitive model is a central feature of the treatment, but the studies in this review used different versions of the cognitive model. Beeson, Rising, Kim, and Rapcsak (2008) use a simple version of the cognitive model comprised of “dual-route model of single-word processing”(p.708) showing the distinction between written and spoken words and their relationship to the internal language concept. Kiran’s (2005) cognitive model shows similar visual and aural inputs but no clear writing or speaking output. Luzzatti, Columbo, Frustaci, and Vitolo (2000) include the “information processing model for picture naming, word naming, and spelling” (p.252). Their model is similar in some ways to the Beeson and colleagues (2008) model but also includes a sole visual analysis separate from the lexical or sublexical language analysis. Beeson, Rising, Kim, and Rapcsak (2010) and Bowes and Martin (2007) mention the use of a cognitive model of language theory but do not elaborate on its implementation. To add to the inconsistencies, Carlomagno, Columbo, Casadio, Emanuelli and Razzano (1991) contrast “phoneme-grapheme conversion procedures or lexical (whole word form) writing strategies” without referring to a model. Luzzatti and colleagues (2000) assert, “if patients are not able to retrieve a direct lexical representation, they will try to compensate the graphemic lexical damage using sub-word-level abilities” (p.251). Here, the phoneme to grapheme sublexical method is not only one tool for the clinician to use in achieving greater writing ability, but also a tool the individual may use independently of the clinician. The cognitive model is integral in formulating the procedures for teaching phoneme-grapheme writing at the phonological level. The lack of a cohesive cognitive model demonstrates that phonological writing treatment research remains...

Find Another Essay On Efficacy of Phonological Writing Treatment

The Impact of Phonological Awareness on the Reading Development of Deaf and Hard of Hearing Students

2908 words - 12 pages . (2002). Phonological awareness: One key to the reading proficiency of deaf children. American Annals of the Deaf, 147, 11–19. Paul, P. (2009) Language and deafness (4th ed.). Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Paul, P. (1998). Literacy and deafness: The development of reading, writing, and literate thought. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Paul, P. & Whitelaw, G. (2011). Hearing and deafness: An introduction for health

What is the Significance and Function of Phonological Rules in Language?

1058 words - 4 pages What is the significance/function of phonological rules in language? Illustrate your answer with reference to three such rules (in English or any language you are familiar with), and give examples of how each rule operates. (968 words)INTRODUCTIONPhonological rules are a system of writing, using formal notation, which allows linguists to express how to pronounce speech phonetically. Phonological rules are part of every speaker's linguistic

phonological summary

635 words - 3 pages implemented for teaching reading and writing. Let’s start with phonological processing that refers to the rules a child uses to detect and discriminating differences in phonemes or speech sounds. It is considered the basic linguistic skill. Having a strong phonological processing skill set is the corner store to learning to read and write. Decoding of printed words is the decoding of the phonemes which then moves into writing of words. These skills

How and to what extent is dyslexia a cognitive deficit? Draw on different explanations of dyslexia to build your argument

1578 words - 6 pages Developmental dyslexia refers to a condition that involves difficulties with reading and writing, learning and retrieving associations between verbal and visual information. Difficulties in dealing with phonological information (speech sounds) within short-term memory have also been identified. Any task that requires the processing of verbal information, mental arithmetic and directional difficulties are also common. Approximately 5% of a

Childhood Apraxia of Speech

1795 words - 7 pages 0% at baseline to 100% accuracy after administered treatment. Accuracy for one final target increased to 60% and 40% accuracy for post treatment data. Although progress was made, the examiners attributed this final target’s outcome measures to late introductory of the phonemes into the client’s repertoire during treatment. This article indicated some efficacy as 75% of tested targets improved to the intended level. There was some effectiveness

Statistical Report on the Effects of Self-Efficacy on Depression

1800 words - 8 pages variables are also interrelated, with higher levels of self-esteem being associated with reduced levels of both depressive symptomatology and loneliness (Ouellet & Joshi, 1996). The relationship between social self-efficacy and psychological adjustment has implications for the treatment of mental health issues because it suggests that an increase in social self-efficacy can increase levels of self-esteem and reduce levels of depression and loneliness

Child Araxia of Speech

999 words - 4 pages . Children were excluded from the study if they had a history of sensory, cognitive, or neurological impairment or if typical oro-motor performance was noted. During the study, changes in speech, phonological awareness, knowledge of letters, word decoding, and spelling skills were examined over 6 weeks using an AB (baseline-intervention) format for each treatment goal. Each child participated in two 6-week intervention blocks with 2 sessions a week

What Is Dyslexia and What Can You Do If You Have It

1429 words - 6 pages foundation of phonemic awareness. Phonemic awareness is a prerequisite of literacy, without a strong foundation of phonemic awareness students will encounter frustration during reading and writing task. It supports the assumption that phonological awareness training is suited to reducing the prevalence of dyslexia in at risk children (Schnedier, W. Ennemoser, M. Roth, E. Kuspet, P. 1999). Early intervention is necessary for students when they

speech disorders

1168 words - 5 pages , but there were no significant differences between the beginning and the end of the maintenance period. This study is a good source of possible treatment for speech impediments in this case Speech Sound Disorder. (Allena, Oetting, and Tyler) Bibliography Allena, Melissa M., Janna Oetting, and Ann Tyler. "Intervention Efficacy And Intensity For Children With Speech Sound Disorder." Journal Of Speech, Language & Hearing Research 56.3 (2013): 865

Learning Disabilities

1666 words - 7 pages Learning DisabilitiesLearning disability is a general term that describes specific kinds of learning problems. It is thought to be a neurological or processing disorder that affects the brain's ability to receive, process, store, and respond to information. It can cause a person to have difficulty learning and using certain skills despite having at least average intelligence. The skills most often affected are reading, writing, listening

Learning Disabilities and How It Effects Lives

1567 words - 7 pages Learning Disabilities Learning disability is a general term that describes specific kinds of learning problems. It is thought to be a neurological or processing disorder that affects the brain's ability to receive, process, store, and respond to information. It can cause a person to have difficulty learning and using certain skills despite having at least average intelligence. The skills most often affected are reading, writing, listening

Similar Essays

Comparing The Efficacy Of Cognitive Therapy And Antidepressant Medication In The Treatment Of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages Introduction Major depressive disorder affects nearly 15 million of American adults in a given year. (Kessler, Chiu, Demler & Walters, 2005). With the impact it has on the society as well as the well-being of the individual, it must be in the interest of the healthcare to be able to provide patients with the most effective treatment method. Extensive research has been conducted on the efficacy of antidepressant medication and cognitive therapy

Efficacy Of Pansit Pansitan (Peperomia Pellucida) Extract As An Anti Hypercholesterolemic Treatment On Rats (Rattus Norvegicus)

1566 words - 7 pages challenges that the whole world is facing right now. Today, a range of synthetic drugs for hypercholesterelomia is available in the market. However, due to the presence of possible side effects of these drugs such as risk of diabetes, potential muscle damage and although more rarely, the occurrence of liver injury (U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 2014), along with the increased efficacy and practicality of various plant-based medicines, there is

Is Dyslexia A Specific Form Of Language Impairment?

1220 words - 5 pages wrong with them phonologically, however it must be noted " the majority of children who are dyslexic have features of both forms of dyslexia" (Ellis 1993) . Ramus (2003) looks at the phonological theory and states it "is still in need of a complete cognitive and neurological characterisation", however " the case for its causal role in the aetiology of the reading and writing disability of the great majority of dyslexic children is overwhelming

Phonological Awareness Essay

5159 words - 21 pages sound in their name with a new sound. The teacher can model this, beginning with easier sounds (common sounds of consonant s, e.g., /m/, /t/, /p/) and advancing to more complex sounds and sound blends (e.g., /ch/, /st/).Most early phonological awareness activities are taught in the absence of print, but there is increasing evidence that early writing activities, including spelling words as they sound (i.e., invented or temporary spelling), appear to
X-Men Evolution | The Lion King 4K Blu-ray | Real Racing 3Il simulatore di corse per chi va a tutto gas