Essay On Honor In Richard Ii

1818 words - 7 pages

The Importance of Honor in Richard II  

 
    The tension-charged exchange between Bolingbroke and Mowbray in the first scenes of Richard II provides exciting action for the audience, and gives a glimpse into trial by combat and the importance of honor in Shakespeare's plays. Trial by combat, or a judicial duel was a traditional way to settle disputes in England and Europe for many generations. People dueled to defend their own honor, and to prove personal claims against the honor of others. Honor. Honor is the accumulation of virtuous deeds that instills a respect in others and in you. Possessing, seeking, and defending the elusive trait of honor are crucial elements of Richard II.

The concept of honor has different meanings to individual members of a modern audience, just as it did to an Elizabethan audience. What is honorable? What makes someone honorable? Aristotle thought:

there is no true honor in the world but that which commeth from vertue. Vertue seeks no greater or ampler theater to shew her selfe in, then her owne conscience. The higher the Sunne is the lesse shadow it makes, and the greater a mans vertue is the lesse glorie it seekes. (qtd. in Council 28)

 

So, by Aristotle's rationale, those people who seek honor are in fact not honorable because they are deliberately seeking honor, which is a vice. Council sums Aristotle's argument very well, "virtue consists in action; the reward of that action is honor; to pursue more honor than virtuous action warrants or to pursue honor for its own sake is a vice" (19). Honor is also eloquently described by Rabelais's definition of honor to the Thelemites, "because men that are free, well-born, and well-bred, and conversant in honest companies, have naturally an instinct and spur that prompteth them into virtuous actions, and withdraws them from vice, which is called honor" (qtd. in Council 29). Are we to belief that honor is an instinct or inborn trait that magically appears? To the Elizabethan audience, birthright would still initially guarantee honor, and respect for a noble, honor that could be lost if it was not maintained or if the gentleman's good name became dirtied. Mowbray

despairs over his lost honor, "I am disgraced, impeached, and baffled here,/Pierced to the soul with slander's venomed spear" (Richard II 1.1.170-171). Honor, being an extremely important commodity in Elizabethan England, was something to fight over.

In Richard II, Mowbray and Bolingbroke are set to have a judicial duel to the death. The duel is judicial because the winner, the survivor, is credited with being true and virtuous. The loser, in death, forfeits claims to honor and innocence. They have told Richard their charges against their rivals, and are prepared to defend their honor, and innocence through personal combat. Their honor, their accumulation of virtuous deeds, has been soiled by the accusations brought against them. Slanderous comments and claims were not to go...

Find Another Essay On Essay on Honor in Richard II

Biblical Figures and Ideals in Shakespeare's Richard II

4164 words - 17 pages position has been mocked and he deposed; Christ, while the soldiers of Calvary "mocked him, coming to him, and offering him vinegar" (Luke 23:36), is addressed as Lord by the dying thief. As St. Veronica offers her napkin to clean the face of the Christ on his final earthly day, the offering of music to Richard in his last hour is poignant and important. In Richard II, William Shakespeare not only created one of the most complex and intriguing

The Importance of the Garden Scene in Shakespeare’s Richard II

1327 words - 5 pages Why is Garden Scene included in Shakespeare’s Richard II? What does it contribute to the overall flow and development of the play?  The Garden Scene (Act III, Scene IV) is an important and pivotal moment, providing plot update, allegory, exposition, and character contrasts. The Garden Scene is important for several reasons, firstly, it occurs between two scenes in which Richard, Bolingbroke, and others are present, but between which

Failure and Success in William Shakespeare´s The Merchant of Venice and Richard II

976 words - 4 pages indefinitely result in defeat. The Merchant of Venice and Richard II show us that when one makes the decision to go against authority it can result in an everlasting change that can be for the better or worse, but ultimately will lead to their eventual demise and destruction. In the play The Merchant of Venice we see the negative effect that rebellion can have against social order that is based on segregation and racism. Shylock, a Jewish man in the play

A Comparison of Corrupt Kings in Shakespeare's Henry IV and Richard II

1119 words - 4 pages A successful monarchy relies upon a stable leader who is concerned with the satisfaction of those he rules over. Henry Bolingbroke the IV in Shakespeare's Henry the IV Part I follows a trend set by his predecessor in Richard II of self-indulgence and neglect of his kingdom. These leaders worry about the possibility of losing their kingdom or their soldiers to other nobles who were also concerned more with obtaining a higher position rather than

Comparing the Murder of the King in Hamlet, Richard II, Henry VIII, Macbeth and Julius Caesar

2780 words - 11 pages Murder of the King in Hamlet, Richard II, Henry VIII, Macbeth and Julius Caesar       Kings are everywhere in Shakespeare, from Hamlet to Richard the Second, from Henry the Eighth to Macbeth; many of the plays contain a central element of a king or autocratic head of state such as Julius Caesar, for example. They focus more specifically on the nature of that person's power, especially on the question of removing it; what it means on both

My Kid Beat Up Your Honor Student - An essay about Anti-Intellectualism in America

835 words - 3 pages Have you ever seen on of the popular bumper stickers that proudly proclaim, "My child is an honor student at such and such school", or the responding sticker that says, "My kid beat up your honor student?" This parental display of resentment toward scholarly students is sickening. The non-honor parent is promoting a ridiculous stereotype through out the country: Smart kids are not physically strong. Something is seriously wrong with American

Essay evaluating the role of women in Richard III

1327 words - 5 pages plot than they seem. Madonne M. Miner, author of the critical essay, "Neither Mother, Wife, nor England's Queen", addresses the women's role in Richard III and concludes that all the women are flat characters, but by doing so she limits the understanding of the affect they have on the audience's comprehension of the plot. The women of this play function as voices of protest and morality. Focusing on the men alone, the play would mostly be about

Black Boy Analytical Text-Based Essay on the End of Racism through "Black Boy" by Richard Wright

1369 words - 5 pages job. They were not individual men, but part of ahuge implacable, elemental design." (229) By teaming up on blacks likePease and Reynolds did to Richard, whites are able to unite and find powerin numbers, and in turn satisfy their human need for pride. Richard wascommanded to distinguish the separation Hand does lead to the separationof the races, and coupled with the ego that the white man at the opticalcompany demonstrated about one's race

Satire and Irony in Poetry with emphasis on Richard Cory and The Unknown Citizen

1640 words - 7 pages of Richard Cory and satirizes the same human condition. It is a narrative about a man who is described as a "saint", who served in "the War", and "had every necessary to the Modern Man" (Auden 20). The poem goes on to describe just how normal this man was: he "held the proper opinion" (23), he was fully insured, and had five children which was the "right amount for parents of his generation"(26). Throughout the poem, the writer praises and lifts

Commentary on Witchcraft, Magic, and Religion in 17th-Century by Richard Weisman

2180 words - 9 pages mind and gain control of them for wrongdoings. An individual can be blinded by evil and can be taken away from God to glorify the Devil. In the book Witchcraft, Magic, and Religion in 17th-Century Massachusetts by Richard Weisman, the writer focuses on the origins of witchcraft in the village Salem in the 17th century. Weisman’s goal is to portray the people accused during the Salem trials as ordinary human beings and not witches; therefore

Essay on Hamlet's evolution of thought through Act III Scene i, Act V Scene i, Act V Scene ii

1375 words - 6 pages /Wherein I'll catch the conscience of the King" (II, ii). There is no problem in finding Claudius's guilt, acting on this new found conviction, however, is tricky because Hamlet must justify killing him. His conscience is the battle between wills: God's and Hamlet's. This means Hamlet must consult his conscience before acting, and therein lays his genius. Most men, Claudius included, wait till sin until being accosted by conscience. He says after the

Similar Essays

The Role Of Women In Richard Ii

2562 words - 11 pages is on recounting the history of Richard II. The Duchess of Gloucester is the widow of Thomas of Woodstock who was murdered before the commencement of the play. At first, there might not seem to be an essential need for a female character playing the wife of a man who has died. However, by including the Duchess as a character in Richard II, Shakespeare is able to pull into the play particular emotions that only a widow would be able to have and

History And Tragedy In Shakespeare's Richard Ii

2246 words - 9 pages History and Tragedy in Richard II         An attempt to sort Shakespeare's plays into neat categories may appear to have its benefits when striving to understand his work, but even a superficial reading of Richard II indicates that this approach is largely futile and sometimes misleading. While it cannot be doubted that the play is of a historical nature, based on events recorded in Holinshed's Chronicles of 1577 and named after an

The Deposition Of Richard Ii In Richard Ii By William Shakespeare

806 words - 3 pages . As Richard lost the support of the nobles and lords, Bolingbroke gained their support. Bolingbroke used this support to depose king Richard II. After the banishment of Bolingbroke, Richard quickly gets back to business and makes plans to go to war in Ireland. There are rebels in Ireland and the king must act to suppress them. But the king has little money; the cost of maintaining elaborate court life has taken its toll on the treasury

Shakespeare’s Richard Ii Essay: The Rape Of A Nation

1508 words - 6 pages , do his subjects have the right to replace him? William Shakespeare's Richard II considers this authoritarian quandary at great length. In particular, John of Gaunt's "other Eden" monologue (2.1.31-68) delves into the perilous nature of unfettered autocracy. Gaunt proclaims that King Richard should relinquish his crown, because he has figuratively raped "mother" England by exploiting the loyalty of his subjects and debasing the grandeur of "this
BDRip.Hun | Heard Island And McDonald Islands | cimatron E13