Eu Law Essay

1490 words - 6 pages

The right of EU citizens to move freely from one Member State to another is one of the fundamental rights of EU law , enshrined in Article 45 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The right to free movement is subject to derogation on the grounds of public policy, public security and public health, together with a more tailored exception in relation to employment in the public service .


As a Polish national, Alec is also an EU citizen . Article 21(1) and Article 45 TFEU guarantees the rights of EU citizens and their families to move freely and reside within the territory of other Member States provided that they are engaged in the internal market economic activity or are financially self-sufficient . As such, he is entitled to move to Bulgaria to work as a plumber. The meaning and scope of the word ‘worker’ is not defined in any EU legislation , but is instead defined in case law. In Lawrie-Blum , a worker was defined as someone who is obliged to provide services to another in exchange for monetary reward. The issue of part time workers was considered in Levin , in which it was held that the rules on the freedom of movement of workers extended to part time workers so long as this work amounted to genuine economic activity . This issue was taken a step further in Kempf , in which it was held that part time work still amounted to genuine economic activity even where the level of pay was below subsistence level and the worker was required to supplement his income by means of public assistance . It is irrelevant therefore that Alec intends to work part time. Alec must move from his home state in order to invoke any rights of free movement.

Charles is not an EU citizen and as such no automatic rights of entry under EU law .Instead, he must rely on Alec’s EU rights as a ‘family member’. Pursuant to Directive 2004/38, a family member includes a spouse, even if they themselves are not EU citizens, and even where that marriage has broken down . Alec and Charles are in a registered partnership and have been together for 5 years. Providing that Bulgaria recognises the status of registered partnership the entry should be granted . Failing that if it is accept that the couple are in a ‘durable relationship’ , they will be required to facilitate Charles’ entry into the country .


As a Portuguese national, Flora is also an EU citizen and as such entitled to assert her rights of free movement as a worker under Article 45 TFEU. She has however been refused a job as a law lecturer as her English skills are minimal. As a general rule, Member States must not limit employment opportunities for ‘foreign nationals’ . However, it may be permissible to demand ‘linguistic knowledge’ where the ‘nature of the post’ requires it . Assuming that the law lectures are delivered in English to English speaking students, the refusal of a job due to Flora’s limited English skills may be permissible provided that the rule is not being...

Find Another Essay On EU Law

Turkey's Accession to the European Union

1189 words - 5 pages countries have to fulfill certain political, economic, and legal criteria for EU membership. Politically, the candidate country must have stable institutions which guarantee democracy, the rule of law, human rights and respect for and, protection of, minorities. Economically the candidate country must have a functioning market economy as well as the capacity to cope with competitive pressure and market forces within the Union. Legally, the

The European Union Vs. A Federal System

978 words - 4 pages autonomous from central authority. Supremacy for EU law over member states law is based on the treaties and can be found in the Van Gend & Loos case (26/62) and the Costa Enel case (6/64). On the other hand the United States also derives its supremacy from its constitution. Art. VI US Const. Federal law, federal courts and Marbury vs. Madison case law confirms national laws supremacy over the states. Constitutional clause? 3. Representation

Identify the different forms of European Union legislation and explain how they become part of English law

1007 words - 4 pages their territories. Britain joined the EU in 1973 when it was still European Economic Community (EEC). So until 1972 UK had complete parliamentary sovereignty" but as the UK's application to join the EU was accepted, Parliament passed the European Communities Act. This Act transferred some control over creation of laws to EU institutions. When talking about where exactly the law comes from, lawyers talk about "sources of law". There

Principal Instiutions and Laws of the European Union

2145 words - 9 pages Law Assignment What are the principal institutions of the European Union? To what extent do these institutions engage with the sources of EU law? Student: Jan Langer Teacher: Philip Benjamin Word Count: 1475 Date: 25 of March 2014 1946 in a speech in Zurich after WWII, did Winston Churchill call for “kind of United States of Europe” (, 2014). 1951 the ECSC is established by Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg and the

"How was the doctrine of supremacy developed by the European Court of Justice, and how was it interpreted by the UK courts?"

1859 words - 7 pages supremacy encountered.The essay will also determine how the doctrine of supremacy has been interpreted by the UK courts from the time when it was introduced up to present day. The essay will also have an area where the future of EU supremacy is discussed."The European Court of Justice has consistently distanced the EU legal system from 'ordinary' international law." As this is arguably likely to cause problems within the EU regarding which law is

The Economic Impact of Integration into the European Union

548 words - 3 pages which EU gives special attention and support as they create about 80 percent of European market. Enterprises of small and medium business strengthen regional economy, help to reorganize its structure, stimulate the development of producing capacity, and promote the creation of new working places. In addition, businessmen will be protected by the EU law and other EU member states will invest money into Lithuanian enterprises.Equally important is

The European Union and Persona Data Protection

1742 words - 7 pages Nowadays, more people give away their personal information on social networks without realizing the potential threats. Under EU law, personal data is defined as ‘any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person.’ While under Article 8 ECHR, there is a fundamental right for the privacy of your life. The Directive 95/46/EC sets a landmark in the history of data protection within the EU. In January 2012 the Commission

UK Legislation: The Preliminary Reference Procedure Under Article 267 TFEU

1997 words - 8 pages . The interpretation of the Treaties ; 2. The validity of EU measures, bodies, offices or agencies of the Union . These can either be discretionary or mandatory . The function of the preliminary reference procedure is to make sure the interpretation and validity of the EU law is the same across all member states. Who can make a reference? Any court or tribunal can make a reference on EU legislation to the ECJ. In order to determine the meaning

Principle Economics

588 words - 2 pages purchases. Thanks this customer have a whole range selection. The European Union want to create common market concerning on the principles of free movement of goods, free market economy and free competition, giving priority to the effective sharing of resources. The EU has already implemented law regulations which help in shaping undistorted competition in the internal market and strengthening the competitiveness of industry. This short paper

The Enlargement of the European Union

2433 words - 10 pages : Economic achievements and challenges’. European Economy 1 (Provisional Version). Pp 5-37; 49-78; 111-134; 151-195. Forgue, D.G., Kehoskie, N.S. 2007. ‘Enlargement Fatigue in the European Union’. International Law News. Vol 36 (2). Spring 2007. Pp 1-2. Mulle, E.D., Wedekind, G., Depoorter, I., Sattich, T., & Maltby, T. 2013. ‘EU Enlargement: Lessons from, and prospects for’. IES Working Paper 3. Pp 8-39. Murphy, A.B. 2006. ‘The May 2004

The United Kingdom Should NOT Leave the European Union

1260 words - 5 pages other countries and there is greater co-operation in Law Enforcement. Therefore if Britain left the European Union it would be insignificant and become isolated. It would suffer in many aspects and British people would have no effect on helping the world. Membership in the European Union means the United Kingdom can trade all products without any additional payments or costly taxes between 27 prevailing economies. The EU is Britain’s largest

Similar Essays

Eu Law Essay

2618 words - 10 pages unusual about this organisation is its function as an, 'umbrella' for the three European Communities, its complementary policies and the forms of cooperation between the Member States. The EU's legal order nevertheless falls a long way short of that of the EC. For example, the principles of autonomy, direct applicability and primacy of Community law, which are so essential to the legal order of the EC, do not apply to the other two pillars of the EU

Eu Ciompetition Law Essay

1222 words - 5 pages their role in the internal market. Also, in the judgment the Court mentioned the importance of the effective and efficient applicant of the EU law. As stated by the Court ‘ actions for damages before the national courts can make a significant contribution to the maintenance of effective competition in the Community.’ Private enforcement refers to the right of individuals to pledge a lawsuit before the court to claim compensation when there is

Eu Law And Legal Aspects Essay

1211 words - 5 pages conflict with European Law. Thereby the three year rule is made impossible by Articles 20 and 21 TFEU. Legal basis for SU The legal basis for foreign European Union nationals to acquire SU in Denmark are the following. First of all, every person who has the nationality of a Member State is also automatically a European Union citizen while not replacing national citizenship which is laid down in Article 20 (1) TFEU. Furthermore, Article 21

European Union Enlargement Eastwards Essay

4465 words - 18 pages EU membership, Russia would have economically and politically stable neighbors. To fulfill the political criteria (presence of stable institutions guaranteeing democracy, rule of law, human rights, and protection of minorities) the Baltic States should reshape their policy toward Russian citizens by ending all forms of discrimination. The European Commission has already urged Estonia to speed up the naturalization process of Russian-speaking
Cultural perspective | Anatomical Terms Of Motion | Read more