Florida V. Buy Gas Co Brief Essay

1516 words - 6 pages

I. Purposes of the Brief
This brief amicus curiae does not address the merits of the predatory pricing allegation against BuyGasCo Corporation ("BuyGasCo"). It speaks only to the nature of the cost accounting system that we, as students of accounting, think to be appropriate for addressing the issues presented by cases of this general type.
We offer our views on this subject out of concern about the allocation of indirect costs used in assessing the appropriate gasoline cost value in State of Florida v. BuyGasCo Corporation, 2003-05143 (D. FL. 2003). We regard the allocation system employed in that opinion to be inconsistent with systems in common practice. Use of that system has a potential adverse effect on both the motor fuel retailing industry and the motor fuel market. It should not be employed in judging the issues in the Florida v. BuyGasCo dispute.
This brief aims to aid the court in constructing a more appropriate framework for resolving the indirect cost allocation issues presented by the case. Before proceeding with a discussion of this framework, it may be helpful to the court to know that we agree with the view expressed in the initial decision: that BuyGasCo's cost for regular grade gasoline exceeded their price.
We understand that the court is currently considering BuyGasCo's motion for appeal and that the motion relies heavily on the cost accounting system developed by Dr. J. T. Humboldt. Although we agree with the accuracy and fundamentals of Activity-Based Costing systems such as Dr Humboldt's, we disagree with his allocation methodology and calculations.

II. Background
The Florida Motor Fuel Marketing Practices Act (MFMPA) determines motor fuel cost for non-refiners as the actual invoice price, including associated freight charges and taxes, plus direct labor and reasonable rental value of the outlet attributable to fuel sales. The invoice price by its nature can be directly attributable to each grade of gasoline at a per gallon rate. As such, this cost will be referred to as the "direct cost" for the remainder of this brief. On the other hand, labor and rent (also referred to as "indirect costs") cannot be directly attributable to each grade at a per gallon rate. It is the methodology of creating attribution rates for these indirect costs that is the point of contention between the parties.
From the hearing, the plaintiff alleged that the indirect costs vary in direct proportion to the number of gallons of gasoline sold per month. Consequently, they allocated the costs based on the average amount of gasoline sold per month. The results of this approach were shown in Plaintiff's Exhibit A (Exhibit 1).
Exhibit 1
Plaintiff's Exhibit A
Calculation of Costs and Profits for BuyGasCo Corporation's Gasoline Products
Prepared by Mr. Donohoe, CPA

Regular Plus Premium Total
Avg Monthly Gallons Sold 342,203 127,120 98,178 567,501
Percent of Total 60.3% 22.4% 17.3% 100.0%
Avg Monthly Indirect Costs $20,006...

Find Another Essay On Florida v. BuyGasCo Brief

Easley MLA BIO Essay

1252 words - 6 pages first cases Marshall defended Donald Murray. He was denied acceptance into University Of Maryland Law. Marshall and Charles Houston won Murray v. Pearson in January 1935. Marshall biggest case as lawyer was the Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka. Thurgood was appointed director counsel for NAACP in 1939. In 1940 thurgood prepared his first Supreme Court brief the Chambers v. Florida the NAACP sought to overturn the conviction of the three

Loving v. Virginia (388 U.S. 1)

2051 words - 8 pages case of McLaughlin v. Florida appeared on the table in 1964, the Court was again ready to deal with the question of racial classification. In McLaughlin, the Court ruled as invalid a Florida statute that allowed more severe penalties for cohabitation and adultery by interracial couples than same-race pairs. Justice Potter Stewart in a concurring opinion concluded, “It is simply not possible for a state law to be valid under our Constitution which

Gideon's Trumpet by Anthony Lewis

1703 words - 7 pages Gideon a perfectly harmless human being, rather likeable, but one tossed aside by life. Anyone meeting him for the first time would be likely to regard him as the most wretched of men." Despite this, Gideon had not surrendered his humanity. He still cared about life and freedom and maintained a keen sense of justice; he felt that he had been treated unfairly by Florida and was determined to try to correct it. Gideon was arrested in 1961 and

Yazoo Land Fraud

1012 words - 5 pages state constitution that would include material from the Rescinding Act. James Jackson furthered his attempts to reverse the effects of the scandal by preventing those who claimed Yazoo lands from being able to cession until republicans were in full control (Brief History of Georgia pp. 57-60). However, in the case of Fletcher v. Peck (1810), Chief Justice John Marshall ruled, “that the Rescinding Act had been an unconstitutional violation of the

Abortion in the United States

3719 words - 15 pages . The Brief History of State Abortion Laws Long before Roe v. Wade, states had established their own laws on abortion. The earliest recorded legal restriction on abortion was enacted in 1820 in the state of Connecticut. This law banned abortions through the intake of toxic substances, and was in place for 112 years. The law was ruled unconstitutional in a three-to-one decision by the Supreme Court in April of 1972 (Gazette). In 1967

Gerard Schaefer

1373 words - 6 pages Gerard John Shaefer Jr., was born into an eventually troubled family on March 25, 1946 in Wisconsin, however he lived most of his early life in Georgia. He was the oldest of three children and was born to a week willed mother and an extremely abusive and adulterous father. At the age of fourteen he, and his family, moved to Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. He graduated high school in 1964 from St. Aquinas High School after which he attended Broward

Testing and Maintenance of Disaster Recovery Plans

2307 words - 9 pages with portions of senior and mid-level management positions. Oklahoma, maintains senior and mid-level management level positions that work in combination with the leadership and operations in Florida. In this article, we will discuss employee involvement in the testing and maintenance of the organizations BC/DR plan and the testing of the plan. Furthermore, a brief explanation on the importance of plan evaluation will be examined. Organizational

The Exploration of Hernando de Soto

2967 words - 12 pages fortune in booty from the conquered Inca which provided the opportunity for de Soto to marry and be welcome at the Castillian Court. On April 20, 1537 Carlos V of Spain awarded de Soto a contract to conquer and settle 200 leagues of La Florida. La Florida encompassed all of the land north of present day Mexico from which de Soto could choose. The contract required de Soto to supply the venture, pay his men, and build three forts out of his pocket

Gideon's Trumpet to discuss the various powers in the US Government

2484 words - 10 pages The American political system is a complex structure involving many different parties/actors, each group with its own unique goal and unique power. In order produce a new policy or law, it is impossible for one party to do it alone; compromises must be made, and coalitions are usually formed. It is a complex and maybe a confusing process, in certain situation some actor may appear powerful, other times very weak. The case of Gideon v. Wainright

Illinois vs Wardlow

1708 words - 7 pages the majority opinion, Chief Justice Rehnquist refers back to Terry v. Ohio. In that case, the Supreme Court held that an officer may, consistent with the Fourth Amendment; conduct a brief, investigatory stop when the officer has a reasonable, articulable suspicion that criminal activity is afoot. While "reasonable suspicion" is a less demanding standard than probable cause and requires a showing considerably less than preponderance of the

Jim Crow Laws

1622 words - 6 pages people agree with the Jim Crow Laws. First passed in the North, long before the Civil War, such laws were based on the theory of white supremacy. In the depression-racked 1890s, racism appealed to whites who feared losing their jobs to blacks. (A Brief History of the Jim Crow Laws). The Supreme Court decided that public facilities would be separated by black and white soon to be called “separate but equal”, 1896. Then two years later the court

Similar Essays

Hall V. Florida Essay

2471 words - 10 pages underlying ADP rules take into account neither the intended method of interpreting IQ tests nor the clinical definitions relied upon by the court in Atkins, we hold: (1) The Florida Statute as it currently exists is not “appropriate” and does not comply with Atkins. (2) In violating Atkins, the Florida Statute violates the Eighth Amendment. Works Cited FLA. STAT. ANN. § 921.137 (LexisNexis 2013). Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304 (2002). Brief of

Amicus Brief Hawthorne V. State

1008 words - 5 pages On February 11, 1983 Robert Augustus Harper, Jr., filed Amicus Curiae on the case of Joyce Bernice Hawthorne v. State of Florida, 740 So.2d. 770. This was the third appearance of Hawthorne in the First District Court of Appeal of Florida for First degree murder, second degree murder and now manslaughter. The question raised in the Hawthorne v. State amicus was related to the expert testimony of Dr. Lenore E. Walker, a Clinical Psychologist

Traffic Laws Essay

1694 words - 7 pages The case of Florida v Meyers stated that to have a reason to conduct a warrantless search of the car that was stopped- there had to probable cause to believe that there is evidence of a crime, and it does not cease to exist once the car had been seized.Meyers was being charged sexual battery. The police had pulled over Meyers, while arresting him from his car. The police officers searched his vehicle and found several incrementing items. The

Bush Versus Gore Essay

730 words - 3 pages with the 14th Amendment. The argument in Bush v. Gore occurred on December 11. Theodore Olson delivered Bush's ejaculatory argument and New York lawyer David Boies argued for Gore. During the brief period when the U.S. Supreme Court was contemplating on Bush v. Gore, the Florida Supreme Court provided clarifications that the U.S. Supreme Court had requested on December 4 in the case of Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvassing Board. Because of
Watch movie | Koisuru Tenshi Angelique: Kagayaki no Ashita OVA English Subbed | Ch.191 : Although Their Expressions are the Same