Georg Lukacs, &Quot;The Ideology Of Modernism&Quot;

9742 words - 39 pages

The Hungarian Marxist literary critic Georg Lukacs (pronounced GAY-org LOU-cotch) was one of the premier theorists of socialist realism, the only acceptable style of literature in the Soviet Union. In order to champion realism, and specifically an ideologically charged realism, as the only good way to write, Lukacs had to set himself in opposition to the literary movement that had superseded realism in the West, modernism (writers like James Joyce, William Faulkner, Robert Musil, and so on). This essay is his attempt to distinguish the two absolutely, in favor of course of realism.

Basically, for Lukacs (and for the Soviet Union), modernism is the last desperate cry of a dying economic system, capitalism. As "late" capitalism crumbles, it generates more and more alienation and meaninglessness in its citizens, and modernism is the attempt to reflect that collapse of value and meaning and human belonging in literary form. Because capitalist society is too corrupt and too chaotic to find meaning any longer, modernists insist that there is no meaning anywhere, and people who believe in meaning are just old-fashioned.

Realism, by contrast, grounds literature in human social and political and economic realities. Realistic fiction shows us the way things really are.

There is an interesting irony in this project: realism was the literary movement of nineteenth- century capitalism, and modernism was the literary movement of twentieth-century capitalism. In order to champion realism, Lukacs (and all the other theorists of socialist realism) had to defend an older form of capitalism against a newer -- an awkward position for a Marxist (who must believe in progress, in the future as better than the past) to take. (Next time, in fact, we'll see the German Marxist modernist playwright Bertolt Brecht arguing against realism as a form of nineteenth-century conversatism, and for modernism as the most progressive literary style a Marxist could possibly hope for.) Their argument was that nineteenth-century realism, the premier expression of an earlier form of capitalism (from the era in which Marx himself lived and wrote), was alert to the failings of capitalism without yet having succumbed to them. Nineteenth-century realists like Balzac and Flaubert and Zola were able to pinpoint and analyze the crippling problems of capitalism in their novels. The modernists, living in a later and more chaotic (and transitional -- moving toward socialism!) era, couldn't see things this clearly. They just painted nightmares -- the nightmares they were living as capitalism collapsed.

Lukacs starts off by promising to pay attention to the ideological underpinnings of these two trends (modernism vs. realism), and to avoid the "mistake" made by bourgeois Western critics in looking too closely at "formal criteria" (1127). (Remember that the Russian Formalists, Viktor Shklovsky at their head, had called for close attention to "formal criteria," and by the early twenties in...

Find Another Essay On Georg Lukacs, "the Ideology of Modernism"

Summary of the Ballet "Giselle" Essay

772 words - 3 pages "Giselle" is a romantic ballet choreographed by Jean Coralli and Jules Perrot. Adolphe Adam beautifully composes the music. This ballet was originally performed in Paris in 1841. The production that we viewed in class was from La Salla. "Giselle" is one of the last ballets of the Romantic era. The element that stood out the most to me was how effectively the music and the footwork corresponded. The best examples of this are seen through

Characterization of "Lysistrata" Essay

834 words - 3 pages Lysistrata, first produced in 411 B.C. is a play that represents the frustrations that Athenian women faced due to the Peloponnesian War. Lysistrata, an Athenian woman is the play's heroine; her name is significant in itself, as it means "she who disbands the armies" (Page 467, footnote 2). With the aide of other Athenian women, Lysistrata organizes a "sex strike" in an effort to cease further violence and bring peace between Athens and Sparta

A Summary of "The Perils of Obedience"

691 words - 3 pages In "The Perils of Obedience," Stanley Milgram conducted a study that tests the conflict between obedience to authority and one's own conscience. Through the experiments, Milgram discovered that the majority of people would go against their own decisions of right and wrong to appease the requests of an authority figure. The study was set up as a "blind experiment" to capture if and when a person will stop inflicting pain on another as they

"Sylvia Plath- Feminine Side of the Feminist Icon"

2123 words - 8 pages Sylvia Plath was a typical example of her generation, inpatient and greedy for life but this description has a bit different meaning. Plath indeed desired artistic fulfilment but she wanted to be an ideal wife and mother at the same time. When Ted Hughes published his first poetry volume "The Hawk in the Rain" she was very happy that she will follow his footsteps. Throughout their marriage she was in the shadow of her husband and we can

A Feminist Study of "The Dead"

1141 words - 5 pages As the last story of James Joyce's short story collection, The Dubliners, "The Dead" is about a young Dubliner's one day of attending his aunts' party and his emotional changes after the party ends. In the paralyzed city the young man feels the atmosphere of death everywhere. And he often has misunderstandings with people, especially women including his wife. From the main character Gabriel's experience, we can see his personal life is in a

Banned: "The adventures of Huckleberry Finn"

1379 words - 6 pages "Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" by Mark Twain was first published in the United States in 1885 as a sequel to the book "Tom Sawyer." The book, which uses Huck's or the first person point of view surrounds the events of two runaways: Huck Finn and a black slave by the name of Jim. Shortly after publication, the book became controversial because of Huck's casual use of the word "nigger." Due to Huck's careless grammar and the book's

Analysis of "Blood Wedding"

4005 words - 16 pages Federico Garcia Lorca's three plays, "Blood Wedding," "Yerma," and "The House of Bernarda Alba" share many symbolisms. Lorca (Short Biography) wrote about many subjects and objects that often have an unconscious double meaning. These unconscious symbols are known as archetypes, developed by the psychologist, Carl G. Jung. This paper will analyze these symbols using Jung's theory of the archetype. By doing so, the analysis will better explain

"Burning of Los Angeles"

916 words - 4 pages In the book The Day of the Locust by Nathanael West, Tod Hackett is an artist who was scouted to come to Hollywood to learn set and costume designing. After walking around Los Angeles, Tod sees people that are "of a different type"(West 23). Tod wants to paint these people who he believes came to California to die. Throughout the book Tod's painting, "The Burning of Los Angeles", is coming to life. In the last section of the book West has

Rhetorical Analysis of "Huddled Geniuses"

2504 words - 10 pages Immigration; A subject that all Americans have a view that differs from person to person. Todd G. Buchholz a Columnist for The Wall Street Journal, has once again brought the views of the country and his arguments for how America should react in his column "Huddled Geniuses" published on February 4, 2004. He address's the fact that Vincente Fox, the Mexican President, wants to open the borders between Mexico and the United States, and how

A Structuralist View of "Macbeth"

3565 words - 14 pages In "The Structural Study of Myth" Claude Levi-Strauss explains that we can discover a myth's meaning by identifying and isolating what he calls mythemes. Like phonemes in language studies, mythemes are the constituent units of myths and they find meaning in and through their relationships within the mythic structure. The meaning of any individual myth, then, depends on the interaction and order of the mythemes within the story. Many critics

William Blake "The Visionary"

1122 words - 4 pages In one of his note books Blake said, "the nature of my work is visionary or imaginative; it is an endeavor to restore what the ancients call the golden age." Not only is the nature of Blake's work visionary, he claimed to have actually seen visions early in childhood. The first time he saw God was when he was only four; God put his head to the windows, and set to screaming. Four years later, he saw a tree filled with angels. Naturally, such

Similar Essays

The &Quot;Patriot Act&Quot; Essay

1269 words - 5 pages searches."* The First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and political association are put in jeopardy as well by dying entry to non-citizens on the basis of ideology and by the creation of "domestic terrorism." These actions have taken place to reduce or eliminate terrorist activities. "Once a Fourth Amendment protection has been eroded, the resulting loss to our privacy is likely to be permanent."* Access to records in

Effective Settings In &Quot;A Pair Of Tickets&Quot;

1306 words - 5 pages Heritage is something very abstract and hard to understand which is similar to family root. By conveying the rich history and legacy to children through parents, but it seems not the effective way compared with their concerment. In the other way, they maybe almost completely ignorant of their heritage. That is the situation of Jing-Mei in "A Pair of tickets" by Amy Tan. Chinese settings that help Jing-Mei more understand and

Critical Analysis Of Alice Walkers &Quot;Everyday Use&Quot;

653 words - 3 pages Alice Walker's "Everyday Use," tells a story about a young woman, Dee, returning home to visit her mother and sister. What should be a happy reunion starts out as a humiliating experience for the mother and little sister, Maggie. Dee has embarked on a new life that does not include Maggie and her Mother; indeed, Dee is full of new ideas that conflict with her family's more traditional lifestyle. Dee has even managed to change her name

Themes In Albert Camus' &Quot;The Plague.&Quot;

2461 words - 10 pages allegorical experience of the author living in German occupied France during the Second World War. The book is also read as, the occupation of Algeria by France. Another interpretation of the book is that the book is a critique of totalitarian communist ideology, in which the plague symbolises the repression of the people by a ruthless government machinery. My attempt in this paper, though, is to bring out the various themes present in the novel
Eps9 Nowhere Boys - Season 4 | Watch Series | GM Odore Doctor