Ian Reid. The Short Story. London: Methuen, 1977. A Discussion.

1110 words - 4 pages

Ian Reid. The Short Story. London: Methuen, 1977.

A Discussion.

The intrinsic `properties' of the short story have been in debate for well over a century, often to disparate opinion. Ian Reid however, presents an article that is balanced and unprejudiced, but that simultaneously allows his subtle opinions to be easily ascertained. His views are hospitable and refreshingly broadminded, allowing the reader to derive for himself the right `choice'.

Reid incorporates various opinions and approaches in his chapter concerning the `essential qualities' of shorter fiction writing. He is accommodating to the views of previous generations about the conventions of writing shorter fiction and how they began. The strict regimes pioneered by Brander Mathews and Edgar Allen Poe about 'unity of impression' are granted respect, but are gently revealed to be slightly out of date by today's artistic standards. Such limiting doctrines are neatly contrasted with examples of a more liberal approach, which have been equally successful, such as works by Kafka and Chekhov.

A factor covered by Reid is the `moment of crisis', which is manifested in different ways. One is the notion of the writer concentrating on ."..a single character in a single episode..." (56), revealing him at the climax rather than following his development in the tradition of the novel - such as in James Joyce's 'The Dead'. Yet Reid observes this is not a `concrete' rule. He suggests there are many successful examples where the character's personal crisis-point remains ambiguous, often made known only to the reader - inferring that it is not the event that is important, but rather the approach to it. He too notes that it is often the ambiguity of the short story that makes the impact, rather than following a regimental structure.

As Reid goes on to discuss the concept of `symmetry of design' - that a short story must be precise in the sequence of a clear beginning, middle and end, a concept so favoured by Poe - he surmises that there is no intrinsic rule to command this, and any other approach can be equally engaging. Reid recognises there is much to be said for careful plotting and the famous 'Final Twist`, but realises also the prominent qualities derived from the freedom of the open-ended narrative. Essentially it is clear that Reid regards each development in the history of shorter fiction writing with respect, but also as a stepping stone toward a freedom that allows a more diverse genre of short stories to be created.

Reid`s support for freedom of creativity, with his method of informing the reader of any relevant history on a particular conservative approach, before subtly refuting it with a more liberal offering - is a consistent presence. Although he appreciates the doctrines of writers such as Poe, there is a hint at the opinion that they are now practically...

Find Another Essay On Ian Reid. the Short Story. London: Methuen, 1977. a Discussion.

The Night Before: A Short Story

1906 words - 8 pages see me. Why could he see me and no one else could? Without a second thought i rushed to his house. When i got there i explained my entire story to him. Of course he thought i was messing with him but my traumatic expression said otherwise. “Okay Alex calm down. Lets try to figure this out then. Have you done anything differently in the past 24 hours? Met up with anyone or went anywhere special? Do anything you wouldn't normally do?” Josh asked

A short story Essay

4705 words - 19 pages , or expend at a mere whim. They are immeasurable in value and will follow one to the end of his days. I lost interest in tangibility many months ago my friend, instead I have come to value those things which the common man disregards; nature, a good discussion, freedom, and a nice deep reflection concerning the human condition. So, in a way, I am more rich and powerful than one can possibly conceive, for my desires, and thus luxuries, have no

a short story.. hehe

1290 words - 5 pages It was the middle of the day. The sun was shining and spring was on its way. I remember walking to the shop, only a few minutes away from my house. I noticed a police van drive past me several times, but thought nothing of it. I walked into the shop and bought what I needed.As I walked outside, I once again saw the police van parked across the road. I walked towards the alley way as I always did. It was my short cut. Walking down the alleyway

A short suspense story

2798 words - 11 pages Nick Spong 2nd NovemberEnglish Coursework - Short Suspense StoryThe sun rose over the little market town of Glandhill. It was a beautiful autumn morning sunrise, about 6:30 with no one yet in the centre of town. Only the farm workers in the distance were up, herding the cows in from the fields for the first of their two milking sessions that day. Within the town centre street lights were still on and the roads were clear. Birds began to sing to

Story Telling: A Potent Tool In Ian McEwan's Atonement and Washington Irvin's The Legend of Sleepy Hollow

1643 words - 7 pages Although storytelling can be seen as a form of creative writing, the novel Atonement by Ian McEwan and the short story “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” by Washington Irvin both suggest that storytelling serves as a means for exaggerating actual events. This is significant because the partially deceitful elements tend to mold the reader’s judgment of what really happens. In the novel Atonement by Ian McEwan, Thirteen year old Briony Tallis is

The Banquet- Short Story

2052 words - 8 pages The Banquet- Short Story It was at a banquet in London in honor of one of the two or three conspicuously illustrious English military names of this generation. For reasons which will presently appear, I will withhold his real name and titles, and call him Lieutenant General Lord Arthur Scoresby, V.C., K.C.B., etc., etc., etc. What a fascination there is in a renowned name! There sat the man, in

The Short Story, Paper

792 words - 3 pages Have you ever dreamt of your dream house? Have you ever wanted to invest in the stock market? Have you ever dreamt of winning a large sum of money in a short time? If so, I strongly advise you to read the short story ‘Paper’. In the story, Tay Soon and his wife dreamt of owning a big house so they tried their best to collect their money to buy it. As the stock market was growing interest at that time, they decided to invest some money in the

Short Story - The Thud

1682 words - 7 pages Short Story - The Thud The thud came again. Rose clicked the television on mute, straining her ear against the storm that splattered the roof with a mixture of rain and hail. The soft thump came from the basement, as though someone, or something, had knocked a book to the floor. Rose gripped the arms of the chair and cursed her husband for leaving her alone on a night like this, knowing she was fearful of storms

The Batter: Short Story

981 words - 4 pages Short Story With over a hundred hours of batting practice this season, Paul planted his feet firmly against the soft dirt. He took a deep breath and readied himself for the pitch. The ball bolted towards the strike zone, and Paul started his swing. He swung his bat with perfection. In his head, Paul knew it would be the best hit of the year. “Strike three!” The umpire hollered. It took Paul all but a second to realize that

The Assassin - Short Story

939 words - 4 pages The Assassin - Short Story He just lay there, on the wet ground, for hours. He looked as though he was just casually waiting and that it was perfectly normal to lie on the ground. After a few hours it started to rain heavily, though this did not discourage him in the slightest as he just carried on lying there, looking comfortable and content. Once in a while a car would drive along the lonely road and the people

A Hanging The short story, “A Hanging” by George Orwell,

1015 words - 4 pages A Hanging The short story, ?A Hanging? by George Orwell, poses many problematic and significant questions. Of these questions the one that intrigued me the most was, how does the narrator?s emotions and feelings change throughout the story, and how does this change affect the theme of the story? These questions are significant in general because they are very important to the theme and major conflict of the story. These questions are also

Similar Essays

The Changover: A Short Story Essay

1544 words - 7 pages hilarious joke. "Best friends? Yeah, till the 7th grade. At least, I tried to put up with you- all this while." "Put up with me? But, Roxanne...What about those times when we had so much fun together? What about those times when I told you my secrets?" "You're really dumber than I thought you were. You really don't get it, don't you?" Then, she shoved me out of the way and added, "Wait up for the exciting events." I shut my eyes for a moment

The Golden Locker A Short Story

1865 words - 7 pages muttered as I left "It's about time."I paced home by my usual path home, a quiet industrial area in the centre of Sydney. I was really exhausted when suddenly I took notice of discrete voices coming from an eighteenth century style warehouse. It stood as tall as a two-story house and was about one hundred metres by fifty metres. The voices intrigued me, as I hadn't heard a voice from that warehouse for the two years I walked by this route. Since I

A Short Story The Old Days Again

912 words - 4 pages and go get something to eat. Tell you the first thing that I did was go see the dunnie to take a whiz. Then I went and made myself a peanut butter sandwich. Tasted good it did. It was about three o'clock when grandpa called me back to hear the rest of the story.He then went on with his story. "Well you know how your great-grandpa's plane went down. Well now he's wandering the musty forest. It's dawn but it's still quite dark, he hears gun-fire

The Adventures Of Jackey: A Short Story

2924 words - 12 pages out in fear. A wolf growled then there was a shattering 'bang' - followed by a deafening silence. Jackey felt a wave of chills spread from the back of her neck down her spine and then to her toes. She started breathing in a panicked manner of short breaths while she was tugging at her binds to get loose. She kept on tugging for a while and just as the bindstretched far enough she slipped her one hand free. She started working on the other hand
ISCOM 473 Week 5 Learning team Assignment Strategic Global Logistics Paper | Larry Green | Kiba: TV Animation