Similar Themes In Both Roger Malvin's Burial And The Minister's Black Veil By Nathaniel Hawthorne

3309 words - 14 pages

In both “Roger Malvin's Burial” and “The Minister's Black Veil,” Nathaniel Hawthorne centralizes the themes of sin, guilt, and repentance. Both are very much set in terms of what defines sin and, in turn, what would constitute action leaving an opening for forgiveness, and both leave many a question unanswered in the story being told. The main question for us becomes, then, one of applicability. Does either story hold a message, if so, what? In considering the two, it may be that they do indeed hold a message, but maybe that message is not one that Hawthorne himself could ever have intended. In this paper I will deal with the themes of guilt, sin, repentance and how Hawthorne developed them in both stories.
Considering first “Roger Malvin's Burial,” the reader is immediately caught off-balance in terms of the presentation of the background to the story. A battle has been fought and won. This, in the introduction, is presented in a fashion when Hawthorne tells us that “The battle, though so fatal to those who fought, was not unfortunate in its consequences to the country; for it broke the strength of a tribe and conduced to the peace which subsisted during several ensuing years” (20). In this lack of empathy for the Native Americans protecting their own homeland, we may realizes from the beginning that we are dealing with a writer whose sensibilities we may not ourselves share. As the story develops, this tends to be confirmed.
Two men, Reuben Bourne and Roger Malvin, have survived the battle and are trying to make their way back home. Both are wounded. As they stop in a forest by “…a young and vigorous sapling stood…,” Malvin entreats Bourne to abandon him and save himself (20). The men are familiar with one another and, at first, Bourne refuses to do so, stating that “I will dig a grave here by the rock, in which, if my weakness overcome me, we may rest together; or, if Heaven gives me strength, I will seek my way home” (21). However, Malvin insists on Bourne's departure, enlisting the argument. The argument is that Bourne should return to his betrothed, Dorcas, Malvin's own daughter to make account of his passing should that be the case and that, in any case, it may be that Malvin has overestimated the severity of his wound and may survive. Thus Bourne, in departing, may be able to bring help.
Bourne, Hawthorne makes clear, is “susceptible” to the argument when considering Dorcas, inclined to give acceptance to the argument given Bourne “selfish motives” in wishing therefore to return in order to be with her. Malvin finally prevails in his argument when he recounts an earlier experience he himself had in which he left another in just such a state, returning in time to save him. Bourne does indeed decide to leave, but not before collecting what meager food he was able from his surroundings for Malvin's sustenance, after which he “... bent the oak sapling downward, and bound his handkerchief to the topmost branch,” the better to guide any...

Find Another Essay On Similar Themes in both Roger Malvin's Burial and The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne

The Minister’s Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne

1762 words - 8 pages Witchcraft and a Black Veil The setting of “The Minister’s Black Veil” by Nathaniel Hawthorne occurs in Milford, Massachusetts which is less than 60 miles from Salem, a small town famous for putting hundreds of people on trial and sentencing several to death as a result of accusing them of witchcraft. The thematic historical similarities between the Salem Witch Trials and Hawthorne’s “The Minister’s Black Veil” is apparent through the use of

Main Themes of Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and The Minister's Black Veil

796 words - 3 pages Main Themes of Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and The Minister's Black Veil Nathaniel Hawthorne’s works often have parallel themes and similar characters. His approach is quite gloomy and the atmosphere for his stories is many times sad and depressing. Hawthorne concentrates his novel and short stories around the Puritan community, which adds to the tense and unforgiving atmosphere. One of his most renowned novels, The Scarlet

The Minister's Black Veil

1122 words - 4 pages Minister's Black Veil," Nathaniel Hawthorne seeks to showcase the flaws of a society in which its members wear and create false facades by illustrating how it separates and alienates the individual from society, peers, reality, and spirituality. In The Minister's Black Veil, Parson Hooper uses his black veil as a way to represent an individual verses their hidden sin. He sees each member of his community as having a black veil, which they can only

Alienation in The Minister's Black Veil

678 words - 3 pages Alienation in The Minister's Black Veil "The Minister's Black Veil" by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a story about one clergyman's alienation due to his outward dressing. Reverend Hooper was a well-respected preacher who got along well with the townspeople until one day when he appeared wearing a black veil over his face that consisted "of two folds of crape, which entirely concealed his features, except the mouth and chin" (Hawthorne 253). From

The Real Courage-Comparison between the central characters in "Roger Malvin's Burial" and "A Good Man is Hard to Find"

2469 words - 10 pages Courage is not a virtue which can be defined in one broad stroke. Nor can it be easily under adverse conditions. In "Roger Malvin's Burial" by Nathaniel Hawthorne along with "A Good Man is Hard to Find" by Francis O'Connor, a lack of courage can be seen in two distinct ways. In "Roger Malvin's Burial", the protagonist, Reuben Bourne, is haunted by a looming sense of guilt from the knowledge that he did not come back to provide a proper burial

Minister's Black Veil

893 words - 4 pages a moral message. When Mr. Hooper was breathing his last breath, he saw everyone around him with a black veil. The moral message, is in life everyone wears a black veil to hide their sins and vices form the outside world. Everybody?s appearance on the outside is hiding what they are really feeling inside.Another critical essay, was written by Ronald E. McFarland. Community and interpretive communities in stories by Hawthorne, Kafka, and Garcia

This essay compares and contrasts the sin in Nathaniel Hawthorne's short stories "The Birthmark," "The Minister's Black Veil," and "Young Goodman Brown."

1035 words - 4 pages perhaps what the minister intended as he says, "I look around me, and lo! on every visage a Black Veil!" (Hawthorne, "The Minister's Black Veil," 759) seemingly convicting all people of having sins that they are hiding and need to recognize. Nathaniel Hawthorne not only describes the sin in every human being in this story, but also preaches that one should not look down upon another for their sins when they too have sinned.Though the previously

The Minister’s Black Veil by Nathaniel Hwathorne

1130 words - 5 pages Nathaniel Hawthorne, a well-known American novelist in the Romantic era, wrote and published the short story, “The Minister’s Black Veil,” in 1836. The story provides an intriguing case of the moral and psychological facet of a religious man and his community during New England and Puritan Age. The tale begins with the villagers gathering on the front porch of the Milford meeting-house to wait for Reverend Hooper. Parson Hooper arrives, and to

Dissection of inclusion and exclusion in "Bartelby" (Melville) "The Sculptor's Funeral" (Cather) "The Minister's Black Veil" (Hawthorne) and the novella "Of Mice and Men" (Steinbeck)

1321 words - 5 pages delicate nerves was forced to leave the meeting-house." (Hawthorne) Here we see, not only in the effect, but in the wording, that a unique quality can alienate a person from a group. Although nothing more than "a simple piece of crape" the black veil changes the emotional visage of the minister, adds power to his sermons and plants seeds of trepidation and awe in the townsfolk. To be a unique quality, a characteristic does not have to manifest

The Essence Of Symbolism In "The Minister's Black Veil"

1324 words - 5 pages The short story, "The Minister's Black Veil" is by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Hawthorne is known for using strong symbolism in his stories. The symbolism in this story is from a black veil that Reverend Hooper wears to a service one Sunday morning and then continues wearing it for the rest of his life. There are many theories as to why Reverend Hooper wears this veil over his face. This veil changes the life of Reverend Hooper and literally all of the

Emotional Guilt in Nathaniel Hawthorne´s The Minister´s Black Veil

1701 words - 7 pages Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Minister’s Black Veil is a story of guilt, humility, sin, hypocrisy, love, compounded emotional stability and trials of life. It is a work of gothic literary art that describes the complexity of emotions and the psychological give and take that takes place when processing and dealing with any human emotion. The gothic writing style Hawthorne uses in The Minister's Black Veil makes it easy for him to focus on one main

Similar Essays

The Minister's Black Veil By Nathaniel Hawthorne

808 words - 3 pages The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Minister's Black Veil" embodies the hidden sins that we all hide and that in turn distance us from the ones we love most. Reverend Hooper dons a black veil throughout this story, and never takes it off. He has discerned in everyone a dark, hidden self of secret sin. In wearing the veil Hooper dramatizes the isolation that each person experiences when

The Minister's Black Veil By Nathaniel Hawthorne

1641 words - 7 pages The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne "The Minister's black veil" by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a story of a life of a clergyman Hooper which leaves the reader with the feeling of sacrifice but also a sort of a personal tragedy. The reader becomes acquainted with the protagonist at the crucial moment of his life, the moment in which he decides to wear a black veil on his face. The very beginning of the story is

Hidden Sins In "The Minister's Black Veil" By Nathaniel Hawthorne

1117 words - 4 pages 'The Minister's Black Veil', a literary masterpiece written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, was a divergent parable for the period it was written. Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote as an anti-transcendentalist in the transcendentalist period; as a result, his view's in writings were mostly pessimistic considering his family's sinfulness. Hawthorne's grandfather was a judge in the Salem witch trails; for that reason, he was responsible for over twenty innocent

The Slippery Slope: An Analysis Of "Roger Malvin's Burial" By Nathaniel Hawthorne

1233 words - 5 pages the initial one until the main character loses sight of what is right anymore. Hawthorne believes that all the answers for the character lies inside of himself, by composing this short story Hawthorne emphasizes what can go wrong, within a person's mind. In "Roger Malvin's Burial", Nathaniel Hawthorne illustrates the slippery slope of forsaking a promise by showing that lies lead to guilt, guilt breeds madness, and that madness evokes
13 Reasons Why | Power Rangers Megaforce (45) | First Touch Games Ltd.