The Exhumation Of Three Mandela Corpses By Mandla Mandela

3246 words - 13 pages

The content of this research focuses on two broad themes: The exhumation of three Mandela corpses by Mandla Mandela, and a study on Xhosa and in some instances, specifically Tembu culture and burial tradition. The Mandela family feud will be examined and a study of how traditional Xhosa culture has or has not changed today, as these aspects of the topic are vital aspects of research that will enable allow a conclusion to be drawn about whether Mandla Mandela’s actions were or were not culturally and ethically correct.
According to Maylie (2013: a and b) the Mandela ‘family row’ began in 2011 because Mandla Mandela (Nelson Mandela’s eldest grandson) had the bodies of his uncle, Thembekile ...view middle of the document...

However, the sixteen Mandela family members who filed the case did so years after the bodies had been exhumed from Qunu and reburied in Mvezo, and when questioned about this, made no comment. It is also important to realise that traditionally, in Xhosa culture it is considered best to be buried where you were born (Ngqulana, 2013). Nelson Mandela was born in Mvezo in 1918, and moved to Qunu when he was 2 years old (Maylie, 2013). If Mandla Mandela had wished to justify his actions, he could have claimed that he was simply following tradition by making way for his grandfather to be buried in Mvezo, his birthland, with his children and grandchildren. Mandla Mandela excused his actions by stating that he had ‘promised his grandfather he would improve the lives of those in Mvezo through development’ and that ‘the museum [was] a part of that effort.’ (Maylie, 2013).
Although having Nelson Mandela’s body buried in Mvezo would be a lucrative tourist attraction, it would generate income that, if used for the benefit of the Mvezo community, would indeed ‘improve [their] lives’ (Maylie, 2013 ). Mandla Mandela’s spokesman, Freddy Pilusa, said Mandla Mandela had in the past said he wouldn't oppose ‘a repatriation of the remains’ (Maylie, 2013 ). implying that he was acting ethically and honourably and wasn’t attempting to force any family member or elder to support his actions.
However, in anger, Mandla Mandela later began slandering his relatives, calling several ‘illegitimate’ offspring (Maylie, 2013 ). King Buyelekhaya Dalindyebo of the Thembu tribe, the clan to which the Mandela family belong, threatened to confiscate Mandla Mandela’s chieftancy as he felt he was ‘bringing shame on the family’ (Starkey, 2013).
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, reacting in response to the family feud said: ‘Please, please, please may we think not only of ourselves…It's almost like spitting in Madiba's face.’ (Maylie, 2013 ). He implied that fighting amongst themselves and (in Mandla’s case) acting in self-interest, was dishonouring all Mandela stood for in a personal capacity.
From the above study of the Mandela family feud, one can clearly see that the actions of Mandla Mandela were unethical because he acted in self-interest: he did not seek the permission of the Mandela family or village elders to exhume the Mandela corpses and rebury them in Mvezo. Madiba’s desire (stated legally in his will) was to be buried with his children and grandchildren in their original burial site of Qunu. However, it was Mvezo, not Qunu that was Madiba’s birthplace, and so Madiba broke a Xhosa burial tradition. Mandla took advantage of Madiba’s wish to be buried with his children, by exhuming the bodies and reburying them in Mvezo, MANDLA MANDELA’S chief lands. Because Madiba is considered a hero of The Struggle against Apartheid world-wide, many people would wish to come and visit his grave on pilgrimage to honour him. This is why Mandla built a visitor’s centre-as chief of Mvezo and owner...

Find Another Essay On The Exhumation of Three Mandela Corpses by Mandla Mandela

Biography of Nelson Mandela Essay

1581 words - 7 pages herding and other rural pursuits. He was one of thirteen children, and had three older brothers all who were of higher rank. Mandela's mother was a Methodist, and he followed in her footsteps by attending a Methodist missionary school. When he was just twelve years old his father passed away. Since Nkosi Mandela was the "principal counsellor to the Acting King of the Thembu people, Jongintaba Dalindyebo" (Nelson Mandela Foundation). The young

Comparing the Teachings of Nelson Mandela to Cry, The Beloved Country by Alan Paton

994 words - 4 pages In Cry, The Beloved Country by Alan Paton and in many of Nelson Mandela’s famous speeches, I have been able to notice many parallels between the messages Mandela always left his audience with, and the concluding chapters of the novel. Throughout the ending of the book, the characters are taught to accept the past, a key teaching of Mandela as well as look towards a brighter future- another main lesson Mandela shares with us. Overall, Nelson

Trials & Tribulations of Nelson Mandela

1107 words - 4 pages Mandela would have to pick-up leadership from underground headquarters. Because of this, Mandela had to move from place to place, leaving his family behind. He had to avoid detection from the government informers and police spies. He did so by dressing in disguises as a common labourer and chauffeur. These disguises earned him the title of 'Black Pimpernel.'In 1961, Umkhonto We Sizwe was formed and Nelson was elected 'Commander-in-Chief.' In

Nelson Mandela or Rolihlahla: Pulling the Branch of a Tree

952 words - 4 pages marriage, organized by the chief that adopted Mandela upon the death of his father. Again determined to stand for his beliefs, he fled to Johannesburg to avoid the marriage. He worked hard and found ways to support himself, help others and continue his education. Mandela showed exceptional intelligence as he valued the importance of education. He affirmed, “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” During his

The Death of Nelson Mandela and the Asian Tsunami

1675 words - 7 pages image with a timeline of Mandela's life. The Daily Dispatch had a special edition containing a front page obituary and and the of the former president with the caption “Madiba is dead.” A very moving image of Mandela with a tear in his eye stating “The World Weeps” was printed by The star. Figure 2: South African newspapers with the news of Mandela's death. Global media houses were also announcing the death of Mandela on their front pages. The

Presence of Christmas: The Loss of Nelson Mandela

2127 words - 9 pages On Sunday, December 8, 2013 7:05 AM, Dwight Sullivan wrote:      “Presence at Christmas”             Luke 6: 27-31                  12/08/2013   Only 20 days until Christmas, the world lost a noble presence.  Nelson Mandela, the first President of South Africa who was elected by all the country, died at age 95.  The AP article in the Whittier Daily News said he was “South Africa’s first black president, who spent

Exploring the Life and Achievements of Nelson Mandela

613 words - 2 pages father’s third out of four wives. (Aikman 70-71) The South Africa that Mandela was born into was prone by the rule known as apartheid, which was a powerful system of racial segregation that essentially denied Black and Colored people rights that applied to the White minority population.(The History of Apartheid in South Africa, Web) Though he had twelve siblings, he was the first in his family to attend school, where his teacher gave him the English

The Ending of White Minority and Nelson Mandela

2550 words - 10 pages . His father was of political importance in the tribe. Mandela received a quality education. He then moved to Johannesburg, where he studied law at the university of Witwaterstrand. He earned himself a degree of law. In 1947, he set up the first Black law firm in South Africa, to work against Apartheid. In his youth he felt naturally felt oppressed by Apartheid to such an extent he went to a protest boycott. Unfortunately

Nelson Mandela: A Hero of Today

1140 words - 5 pages Nelson Mandela (1995) writes, “No one is born hating another person because of the color of his skin, or his background, or his religion.” Although, Nelson Mandela was imprisoned for 27 years, he spent his entire lifetime redeeming the freedom of the South African black and colored society from facing misery set by the government. However, after Mandela was freed from prison, he became South Africa’s first president whom all could vote for

Nelson Mandela and the South African Apartheid

2275 words - 10 pages nation that has been pierced for years by Apartheid seemed impossible for blacks. Mr. Mandela however, was the exception to that perception. His immense contribution to South Africa and his people ultimately resulted in the greatest legacy of South African history. Despite the turmoil and resistance he was facing he still came out victorious becoming the first black president of South Africa in 1994, serving until 1999. Nelson Mandela whose birth

Effective Use of Non-Violence by Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King and Nelson Mandela

859 words - 3 pages returning to India to fight the caste system by doing chores an untouchable would do. He fought the British Salt Tax by initiating "The Salt March". Nelson Mandela fought the government through non-violence to abolish the apartheid laws in South Africa. Mandela spent almost twenty-seven years in prison, where his hunger for the freedom of his own people became a hunger for the freedom of all people, black and white. Martin Luther King Jr. led a

Similar Essays

The Legacy Of Nelson Mandela Essay

1579 words - 6 pages power and overruled the veto. This put into effect the prohibition of full trade embargo with South Africa. The bill was affective. South Africa began to struggle, causing the minster to put an effort into compromising with the wants of the black Africans. To this day the type of activism protesting introduced by students with the intent of changing South Africa’s apartheid and freeing Nelson Mandela has become a protester staple. The boycotts are

The Legacy Of Nelson Mandela Essay

1169 words - 5 pages the hands of your government, would you feel that the machinery of that government to be fair game in a guerilla campaign? How about targets such as the South African Air Force HQs? Obviously Mandela couldn't raise a formal army per se, what with the highly effective military, police, and intelligence resources focused on suspected dissidents. So Mandela's tactics in his asymetrical fight against the government were described by a subordinate

Nelson Mandela: The Art Of Civil Disobedience

1150 words - 5 pages Nelson Mandela: The Art of Civil Disobedience Have you ever wondered what it was like to make a difference and even change something in your country? How would you feel if you were considered a hero by your people? Civil disobedience is a form of protest that uses a law to show that it is not needed. The protestors intentionally violate a law that they are protesting against (Suber). For example, Rosa Parks used civil disobedience by sitting at

The Life And Work Of Nelson Mandela

1562 words - 6 pages Apartheid, the official policy of racial segregation practiced by the South African government. The Apartheid affected every aspect of life in South America. A Black South African may have had the same exact job as a White South African, but could have made the less in an entire year that the White South African made in a month. This inequality and perjury of justice greatly distressed Nelson Mandela. His distinguishing
Bussiness Survey... | Kimrie Lewis | Game of Thrones 1x3