What Combat Requires In Philip Caputo's Rumor Of War

1661 words - 7 pages

The Vietnam War was a psychological and physical battle for all the young men who were drafted or volunteered. Caputo's own reasons for volunteering illustrate the mentality for some of the men entering into this journey. Those who are inducted into Vietnam face disturbing moral dilemmas that can be expected in an "ethical wilderness." The draft introduced a myriad of young men to the once forgotten moral ambiguity of war. Average American citizens must balance right from wrong in a world without morals or meaning. Caputo himself struggles with the idea that killing in combat is morally justified.

Philip Caputo joins the Marines for the same reasons most young men leave their home city or town. He wants adventure, an escape from the mundane and the idea of being a hero; Caputo dreamed of being "John Wayne in Sands of Iwo Jima," storming the beaches as only a Marine could. Adding to this formula is the Kennedy inaugural speech. The President is asking how "you" can help the United States of America. Being a child stuck at home with his parents, the idea of joining the world's "911" force is an ideal romance for one so young.

Laws exist to protect life and property; however, they are only as effective as the forces that uphold them. War is a void that exists beyond the grasps of any law enforcing agency and It exemplifies humankind's most desperate situation. It is an ethical wilderness exempt from civilized practices. In all respects, war is a primitive extension of man. Caputo describes the ethical wilderness of Vietnam as a place "lacking restraints, sanctioned to kill, confronted by a hostile country and a relentless enemy, we sank into a brutish state." Without boundaries, there is only a biological moral compass to gauge appropriate actions and responses; there are few people to say "these actions are morally unacceptable." Vietcong forces use civilian villages as ambushes. This creates dangerous situations for both the civilians and the Marines. It is human nature to preserve one's own life even if it means killing another to accomplish this. There is no time to react in an ambush scenario, no time to decide who is Vietcong. This very situation is illustrated when Caputo and his platoon burn down a village suspected of housing a Vietcong ambush.

The ethical wilderness introduces the rules of engagement in many respects. Nobody wants to die in combat, especially when loss of life can be prevented. To Americans, it is nearly impossible to differentiate between Vietcong soldiers and civilians. In many instances, the two are interchangeable. A natural response is to engage anyone who is not an American or not where movement is expected. However, rules of engagement are created to prevent the slaying of noncombatants to include civilians and medical personnel in the like. These rules are not concrete, but in fact, they are very fluid so as to prevent ambiguity in changing circumstances. Marines with nervous trigger...

Find Another Essay On What Combat Requires in Philip Caputo's Rumor of War

A Rumor of War. A brief history of the events leading to the Vietnam war, and a critical analaysis of the novel "A Rumor of War"

1688 words - 7 pages and romantic, but after reading Caputto's The Rumor if War it is easy to argue that the Kennedy administration's decision to deploy and later escalated the presence of American military force in Indochina did very little to oppose our communist foe, the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong, and did even less to assure the survival and success of liberty.Following the Great Depression and World War II the American public had an unprecedented sense of

Paper on the Vietnam experience from the book "Rumor of War"

773 words - 3 pages war must be conducted. Caputo ordered an unauthorized raid into the village to capture and kill if necessary the two Vietnamese; and his men carried the orders through and killed the victims, of whom had no indications of being VC. So in the tradition of justice the military upheld their image by looking into the incident. And this they did doubly so, by coming to the conclusion that the defendants were all good and honorable soldiers with clean

Evolution of the Engineer in Combat

1834 words - 7 pages knowledge of the land and terrain became extremely valuable. Engineer officers started taking on a new role, which would eventually evolve into what we know today as “combat engineers.” The engineers starting carrying weapons and began to lead units of infantry soldiers into battle. During the Civil War, engineers were pivotal in the defense of Washington. Through use of strategic fortifications, the engineers were able to defend Washington

The Breakdown of Women in Combat Situations

1269 words - 5 pages have to do more work to make up for the woman's weakness (Spiecel 46). Soldiers must have confidence in the physical strength of their comrades. Relying on a woman's strength in combat sets a unit prone to failures (Aspy 141). Women do not need to be allowed in combat to please a handful of feminists that believe they have the right to serve on the battlefield.The purpose of an army -- any army -- is not to cultivate idealism or to score points

Writing in the Style of Philip Larkin

961 words - 4 pages his long fingers grip the throat of the man in the back. I yell out “What’s Happening?!” “Its not good, Hurry” she replies. I can hear her doing CPR. The soft banging of her hands on his chest. The whir of the oxygen machine. Death is smirking at me. He is coming and he isn’t going to stop this time. It must be said that "Ambulances" is one of Philip Larkin's successes. He has described our own venerability and lack of knowledge. He

Analysis of The Poem What Work Is by Philip Levine

2254 words - 9 pages factory work with an impulse to poetry formed the imaginative nexus out of which emanated not only Levine’s first poems, but also to a considerable degree his entire poetic output. After spending several years working at a succession of monotonous, back-breaking, dangerous jobs at factories in Detroit, Phillip Levine attributed his poems to correlate with day-to-day living, in-which a book he published in 1991, What Work Is won the national book

Combat Sports in the Ancient World: General Aspects of Ancient Combat Sports

2688 words - 11 pages success in everyday life”...one can nevertheless assert that the rules...were sufficiently different from the rules of war...to allow us to distinguish the two forms of combat.” Combat sports in the modern world benefit much greater from this definition, considering the rules of modern warfare don’t hold much for hand-to-hand combat nor fencing or other forms thereof. However, a modern equivalent can possibly be found in Poliakoff’s reasoning in the

War Art: Comparison of Tim O'Brien's memoir, "If I Die in a Combat Zone", and the movie "Apocalypse Now", directed by Francis Ford Coppola

1074 words - 4 pages disguised history of the Vietnam War, and war in general. The soldiers did what they were ordered to do instead of what they may have wanted to do. No matter what their emotions or morals, they had to follow through with their commands because they felt pressured by society, the government, their families and friends. Apocalypse Now and If I Die in a Combat Zone show the horror, absurdity and lack of righteousness in war.Works Cited:"Apocalypse Now". Prod. Francis Ford Coppola. DVD. Zoetrope Studios 1979.O'Brien, Tim. If I Die in a Combat Zone Box Me Up and Ship Me Home. New York, NY: Broadway Books, 1999

The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in Combat

1182 words - 5 pages Sue WaggonerProfessor KeeneEnglish 130216 September 2003The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in CombatWhether or not women should be allowed in combat is a question that rests in the minds of many Americans today. Although women are allowed to serve in the military they are still not allowed to serve in combat; why is that? Is it because today women are still not viewed as equal adversaries? These days and times, what exactly is combat? Is

Of Human Bondage: The Women In Philip Carey's Life

898 words - 4 pages through the bonds of "love" and sees Mildred for who she really is - a conniving, callous prostitute.Norah Nesbit is another influential woman in Philip's life. Though Philip doesn't love Norah, she is a positive influence in his life nevertheless. Norah pampers Philip using her motherly instincts and encourages him to do what he can for himself: go on vacation to take a break, and study hard for school to pass his exams. She is successful in

In What Ways Does Philip Larkin’s Poetry Show His Attitude To Death?

2559 words - 10 pages In what ways does Larkin's poetry show his attitude to death? In Philip Larkin's poetry there is a profound sense of unease about death. Larkin, throughout his poetry, obviously contemplates the inevitable end that is death. In his poetry Larkin uses great observational skills, noting and writing about everyday circumstances in cinematic detail. With death, though, Larkin has nothing to observe. He cannot draw any precise conclusions about

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Philip Caputo's A Rumor Of War

1955 words - 8 pages Analysis of Philip Caputo's A Rumor of War A Rumor of War by Philip Caputo, is an exceptional autobiography on a man's first-hand experiences during the Vietnam War. Philip Caputo is a Lieutenant during the Vietnam War and illustrates the harsh reality of what war really is. Caputo's in-depth details of his experience during the war are enough to make one cringe, and the eventual mental despair often experienced by soldiers

A Rumor Of War By Philip Caputo

1745 words - 7 pages War in Literature In every work of literature I have studied this semester, there was a theme of warfare. What made each memoir, documentary, poem and other varieties of genre unique, however, was the perspective it took place in. A Rumor of War by Philip Caputo, for example, is Caputo’s particular memories of war. It is a recollection of his encounters and close calls which make his writing unique to every other work of

A Rumor Of War Essay

893 words - 4 pages In A Rumor of War, Philip Caputo informs the struggles he experienced in Vietnam. During his involvement in the war, Caputo is conflicted with his personal identity and finding the meaning of war. With his desire to prove himself a man and the influence of Kennedy’s challenge to “ask what you can do for your country,” he enlisted in the military (p.xiv). Although Caputo describes his excitement for standing up for his country, he warns the

Without Pain There Is No Happiness In A Rumor Of War By Phillip Caputo

829 words - 4 pages There are many elements use to describe pain and suffering during novels such as, A Rumor of War and the other works that represent war and the other topics within war. Without this common element within these books and other works, war would not be accurately represented. Pain and suffering is a common element used as a tool in literary works such as, A Rumor of War. In the book, Caputo describes the horrendous sights that he saw while
Lace Bodycon Waisted Bowknot Midi Dress | Doll & Em | Kevin.Hart.What.Now.2016.VOSTFR.1080p.BluRay.HD Light.x264-VR46 (S:0/L:0)