Witness Essay

2077 words - 9 pages

Witness Anonymity
“Parliament should never legislate at the speed at which I am proposing unless it is convinced that there are overwhelming reasons for doing so, but I suggest to the House that this requirement is satisfied in this case. Anonymous evidence is these days fundamental to the successful prosecution of a significant number of cases, some of which involve murder, blackmail, violent disorder and terrorism. Such cases could be jeopardized if we do not quickly fill the gap created by their lordships’ judgment” . These are the words of Jack Straw who was the Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor. The House of Commons was discussing the Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act 2008. These discussions were based on the ruling which had been passed in the case of R v Davis . There is a basic common law principle that an accused should be given a chance to confront his accuser whom he should always know .
Due to emergence of advanced crimes, there has been an increased use in necessary protection measures which have even gone outside the statutory scope in order to protect vulnerable witnesses. The introduction of witness protection has come with its challenges. Like in the case of R v Davis the contentious issue that arose was whether the introduction of witness protection would affect the defense and hence interfere with the rights of the accused. In the case their Lordships agreed that the defense had been curtailed and that the conviction was unsafe. This common law principle is only qualified with a few exceptions which are to be expressly stated in a statute. In reaction to the challenges that faced the R v Davis, parliament went ahead and enacted the Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act 2008 and afterwards the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 which repealed the Criminal Evidence Act 2008. It was until the year 2010 that the witness anonymity section came into full force .
According to the Act, the prosecution is entitled to apply for witness anonymity measures . The Act also sets out some conditions that the court should satisfy before allowing such measures; according to section 88 the conditions the safety of the witness, trial fairness and public interest. To mitigate the harshness of R v Davis, section 89 sets out the considerations that the court must put in mind. This relates to credibility, motive and background of witness, the importance or weight of his or her evidence and if the defendant will be in a position to test the evidence.
The issue of witness anonymity is not as straight forward as it seem, this is witnessed in the words of Lord Huth of Kings Heath (Parliamentary Under-Secretary, Ministry of Justice; Labor), who alleges that there has been raising concern on the criminals to intimidate the witnesses in order to escape punishment. He further goes ahead to note that this practice is common in crimes that involve guns, drugs and armed gangs. Such is the fear that is inflicted on the witnesses or the...

Find Another Essay On witness

Witness film close study Essay

790 words - 4 pages The relationship between a character and their world can lead us to a deeper understanding of significant ideas in the text. ‘Witness’ directed by Peter Weir in 1985 effectively demonstrates how a crime fiction genre is explored through the significant ideas of characterisation and a clash of cultures. Ultimately, these aspects created through the relationships between characters and their worlds, allows us to have a deeper understanding of any

International Crime Witness Essay

1630 words - 7 pages and the authority to overrule every decision made by their judges or Supreme Judicial Council; thus, the ability to dispense justice fairly is virtually non-existent. Human rights violations abound in Saudi Arabia. International Crime Witness The Minister of the Interior exercises control over all matters involving arrest and detention. No penal code exists; therefore, persons who violate Saudi Arabia’s laws are subject to arrest as well as

Eye-Witness Testimony

3209 words - 13 pages Eye-Witness Testimony Until now we have focused upon theoretical psychology that employ methods that are removed from real life. Neisser was one psychologist who criticized his fellow psychologists for concentrating too much on theoretical concepts and ignoring the practical issues involved about memory. It is memory from real life experiences that psychologists must concentrate on and one aspect of this is known as

Blood Transfusion on Pregnant Jehovah’s Witness

941 words - 4 pages Blood Transfusion on Pregnant Jehovah’s Witness We all can agree that blood is the most precious liquid that a human being possesses, and without it, life and existence would be diminished. Up to this date, Jehovah’s Witness have refused blood transfusion procedures due to their religion, but this issues becomes more of a predicament when it jeopardize somebody else’s life; a life of fetus in a pregnant woman. Based on Jehovah’s Witness’s

The film Witness with Harrison Ford

525 words - 2 pages WitnessJust as in paintings or drawings, the point of view of any work of art can drastically affect the way that artwork is interpreted, developed, and characterized.The film Witness utilizes the idea of point of view through use of various camera angles and shots to convey different meanings throughout the film. In a way, the director Peter Weir used the camera as the narrator of the film, manipulating what the audience sees on the screen

Witness Uganda and the Greater Good

703 words - 3 pages The Catholic Social Justice Themes of global solidarity, an option for the poor and vulnerable, and a constructive role of government could be used to solve the problems of disunity, a failed responsibility to the poor, and the corruption of local government that arose in the musical Witness Uganda. Global solidarity is an important aspect of social life because it teaches us to understand the unity and wholeness we possess as one human race. We

Analysis of 'Witness' directed by Peter Weir

969 words - 4 pages The Amish are a charming people, gentle oddities in today's techno world. They don't do handguns, cars, or telephones, and they're exceedingly clannish in their desire to keep out technology generally and outsiders in particular. The basis for Witness is an age-old fish-out-of-water story: a modern man trying to fit in with the quaint Amish in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Taken on that basis alone, Witness is a success; it's when the "real

Agatha Christie's "Witness for the Prosecution"

747 words - 3 pages This paper will present a compare and contrast of the short story, "Witness for the Prosecution" to the screenplay of the same name written by Agatha Christie. The focus of the similarities and differences will be, a review of the characters and the story. In both versions there are both likable and unlikable characters that create a gripping tale where you find yourself hoping young Leonard Vole will beat the overwhelming odds stacked

Two Different Worlds in film Witness

2396 words - 10 pages Two Different Worlds in film Witness In the film Witness we are shown the differences between the Amish community in Philadelphia, America, and the modern life of Americans. With Peter Weirs use of the camera we are shown that the Amish world is very secluded and rural compared with the modern world. We see that they are a close knit community with man living in harmony with nature. They are deeply religious who express

Defending the Deity of Christ to a Jehovah’s Witness

1264 words - 5 pages point you wish to represent to them- those who have already learned one thing, and have been studying and practicing it for a number of years, are usually stuck in their preconceived notions. In the instance of witnessing to a Jehovah’s Witness, the Christian explaining the Biblical truth should be sound in their studies and scriptural knowledge. There are several steps that must be taken in order to have an effective witness. First, let’s take

Rights of Victims and Witness within the Military Justice System

2025 words - 8 pages accorded specific rights and certain services. Congress via the President directed the Department of the Navy (DON) meet mandatory requirements in relation to the rights of victims and witness within the military justice system.Today, the U.S. Navy is a benchmark organization in regards to the rights of victims and witnesses. The provisions described in this essay are not limited to offenses prosecuted at courts-martial (equivalent to a felony offense

Similar Essays

Bare Witness Essay

1737 words - 7 pages Bearing witness When we encounter a Holocaust survivor, a lot of questions come to our mind. We start to wonder how did they manage to survive. We tend to assume that once the Holocaust was over, survivors began to reestablish their lives and their pain disappeared. However, Holocaust survivors suffered, and even after 70 years after the liberation, Holocaust survivors still experience difficulties on their day-to-day basis. In the years

Jehovah's Witness Essay

1498 words - 6 pages , William . "www.ewtn.com." What Do JWes Believe?. http://www.ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/JWBELIEV.HTMFind a website by URL or keyword... (Accessed April 15, 2014). Step, Hillary. "What Being JW REALLY Means.....(long post)." Jehovah's-Witness.Net. http://www.jehovahs-witness.net/jw/friends/50819/1/What-Being-A-Jehovahs-Witness-REALLY-Means-long-post#.U1buWsJOW00Find a website by URL or keyword... (Accessed April 19, 2014).

Witness For The Prosecution Essay

1100 words - 4 pages The mystery, “Witness for the Prosecution”, was produced in 1957 by Arthur Hornblow, Jr. and directed by Billy Wilder. The two lead male actors were Tyrone Power as Leonard Vole and Charles Laughton as Sir Wilfrid Robarts. The lead female actor was Marlene Dietrich as Christine Helm. “Witness for the Prosecution” superbly demonstrated a realist view of the operating procedures in a courtroom. The actors within the courtroom were easy to

Eye Witness Testimony Essay

899 words - 4 pages Eye Witness Testimony The language used by the police when interviewing witnesses and barristers during a trial may influence answers given by witnesses, this language may affect initial perception and subsequent recall. Both of these effects are shown in the study by Loftus & Palmer {1974). My experiment into this field showed the leading question with the `verb` contained the information about what the answer
La Verdad HDTV | India Ke Mast Kalandar | Accounts